Waitagoddamnedminute.
Are people genuinely debating about which FF game is the worst based on the angstiness/psychological isolation of the main character?
That's like ranking basketball games based on there being a basketball in the game.
I can't wait to try out XII once I get my

ing exam out of the way. It's sitting there looking so lonely right now. Oh well...anyway, while I am an unabashed Final Fantasy fan (not so much that I am perpetually unemployed yet able to afford Final Fantasy tattoos...not to single anyone out, of course), I try to be realistically critical of the games.
I've liked them all, admittedly, but what looks the most promising about XII is that it appears to have depth and complexity. You can wank on the gambit system, but there's a certain degree of strategy involved in that. I'm hoping that this game has enough depth to avoid the hallmark problems of damn near EVERY FF game: the linearity, combined with level grinding, that just makes the game more of a task than anything else.
Playing some of the FF games (even 4, which was my favorite), I couldn't help but feel as if the game was parenting me; telling me where to go, what to do, what to buy, etc. A few months back I went to see Pirates of the Caribbean in the theaters. I sat behind some mouthbreathers who were discussing the plot intricacies of a goddamned DISNEY MOVIE, as if there was some suggested subplot, instead of every twist and development being played out on the screen. I feel that FF can be the same way: if you feel shocked by any plot twist, or find yourself at a loss for where you need to go next, you're just a fool (or fail to find yourself so bored with a game that you aren't following it). It can be too coddling, IMO.
And the games seem to encourage grinding: enemies in a given area are only so tough, and then the boss of the area is a nightmare. So, you go level grind for 30 mins-2 hours, and mop the floor with the boss, using little more than *attack*attack*attack*attack combos (even the white magicians, y'know?).
XII better not be that way, or else I'll be failing Hanger 18 on expert by the end of the month instead.
For the record, although I thought FFX was a very fun game that went far beyond a Satre level of philosophical bullshit, it's my least favorite because of Wakka. I don't think I would have minded him if there were no voice acting in the game...but there is, so he's goddamned annoying.