[quote name='blitz6speed']Big write up incomming.
Background:
Always into new tech. Had Motion+ day 1, Move day 1 and got Kinect day 1 also.
I own every system out, tried it all, so im very experienced in current gen games + motion controls of all kinda.
Got kinect, Kinect Adventures of course, Kinect sports, Dance Central and Yourself Fitness.
Hardware, i am impressed. Very well built and honestly, it DOES work. That in of itself is impressive that its not smoke and mirrors, it does as advertised.
Gaming wise it is a mixed bag. Here is what i'll say:
Yourself Fitness - First game i tried, it was actually really impressive. It works well and functions exactly how you'd expect. The lag is basically non-existent when you are playing. Block Breaking game is super fun.
Kinect Sports - Following YF, i had high hopes due to so much praise this was getting. Rare is a wildcard in motion gaming and i wanted to get right into it. Sadly, this game is terrible. I think the best thing about this game is raising your hands to have the crowd cheer. Otherwise, its pretty bad. I played Bowling which is so imprecise its awful. Your lane position changes during swing, to do angles you have to throw your arm to the other side, and it guesses at when to throw the ball.
Ping pong was equally awful, i was able to stand still and just barely move my hand and the ball would hit from the other side as if there was a magic paddle there. At times i'd swing on time, then due to lag the ball would move past me, and then magically get hit back.
Volleyball was fun till it came time to hit spikes, i'd jump then swing hard, and it would register as if i tapped it with a sponge. Tried multiple times over and over, everytime, it wouldnt register. I just got frustrated and quit. I am going to go back to it and give it another shot, but so far, its really bad. Boxing was fun but easily exploitable. Took the fun out of it.
Next game up was Dance Central. Game is EXCELLENT. So fun, blast to play, controls work. The only issue i have with it is, is way too few songs. Otherwise its a+, nothing else to say, it works as advertised.
I popped in Kinect Adventures and played Rally Ball. It was ok, works but not very fun. Im going to go back to this again, but everyone here just wants to play dance central so i put that back on for them.
Overall:
Hardware works. I am impressed and am very glad i got it.
Software... INSANELY hit or miss so far. Dance Central and Yourself Fitness are great and work as advertised. The Minigame Compilations so far have failed to impress. After experiencing everything on the nintendo side (wiimote, motion plus, wii fit) and on the sony side (Move), the minigames on those blow away the ones on the kinect for fun and accuracy. Stuff line dancing/fitness, kinect is the hands down winner by a mile.
I would recommend purchasing right now only if you are into dance games (i am as are my large extended family i play with) or fitness games (its rather fun actually). Im hoping to get some more games to try soon. Im interested in joyride in particular.[/QUOTE]
I agree with your review completely...I too have all 3 systems and for Kinect I have Dance Central, Kinectimals and Kinect Sports...
DC is great, the kids love Kinectimals although the throwing in many of the minigames is very inaccurate...the biggest disappointment is Kinect Sports...after playing Ping Pong with the Move, the Kinect version is a joke...bowling is not realistic in that to put spin on the ball you actually have to throw your arm across your body which is not realistic...the track & field and soccer are fun for what they are though and we are enjoying those...for some reason boxing seems more laggy than the other games...
I am also very excited for the potential it offers but when it comes to "accuracy" sports however I am not very hopeful...games like golf may never be what the Move can offer...