There's no question that the lady shouldn't have put the coffee in her lap in a moving car. However, there is no question that MD's was serving thier coffee WAY too hot and they knew it caused problems in the past. The link provided clearly shows MD was at fault. Of course not 100%, the woman was dumb. But had the coffe been at safe, normal tempratures, there would be no lawsuit as their likely wouldn't have been much damage.