Okay, I'm a fan of the series, you've been WARNED!
Max Payne 1 was amazing. Being the first with bullet time, the story was really good, and it controlled pretty well (I'll come back to this). Overall, like Sin City, I found it darker than my usual tastes, but it was a good game... so I had to admit I liked it.
Max Payne 2 - Damn... did folks not like the story? I thought it was INCREDIBLE! Sexy, Serious, Comical, this game had a little bit of everything. There were a few places I was like, where the hell am I supposed to go now? But I'd get past that and man, it was fabulous.
As far as the length of both games... I thought they were pretty well done. I mean, go too nuts and you end up with Duke Nukem forever. Instead, the company spent a year or so coming up with the story, putting together the graphics, and making it all come together. My hats were off to them THEN and NOW. My biggest regret was not being able to find the Max Payne 2 shirt in an XXL. I'd have wore the hell out of it.
CONTROLS - Okay... this is where Max either wins or takes a beating. I should probably mention I played both on the PC first, then tried them on the consoles. But I own every console, and like to think I'm objective. Simply put, Max Payne 2 is NO Halo. Unlike Halo where I got used to the controls and they felt good in short period of time, I couldn't get used to the Xbox or PS2 controls within a reasonable amount of time. It was a shame, because on the PC, both games control SO well. So much so, that I actually played through 2 the 3 times on all three difficulties. *** minor spoiler *** The ending DOES change if you beat it third time on the hardest difficulty, which was TOTALLY cool. I'd highly recommend it, though many may not be impressed if they don't get into the game. Once again, STORY people! *** minor spoiler over.
Overall, Max Payne 2 was my pic for game of the year on PC when it came out. It had guns, the girl, good graphics, an amazing story, and it played SO well on PC. I remember trying to write the folks that wrote the game... I was SO impressed. The idea of no 3 just sucks, and I hope it isn't true. But in all honesty, it's been a while since 2 was released and I'd kind of forgotten about the sequel. I'm currently excited for Halo 3, and which Lucasarts would get off their ass, quit f'n around, and make Full Throttle II like they promised at E3 2002 and 2003. But that's probably a fantasy...
At $2, what do you have to loose? I bought it for $10, didn't like the controls on the consoles, and went back to the PC version. But for $2, that's cheaper than lunch... give the SOB a try and let us know what you think!