Been lurking forever and finally have something to contribute. For those of you that were burned by Best Buy's drop in trade-in values and have a Microcenter near you, here's a possible alternative. Microcenter has some trade in values advertised on their website and in the new sales paper. Notice the trade in value for Crysis 2. I've never personally traded there so if anyone has please post your experiences.
http://www.microcenter.com/storefronts/gaming/used.html
YMMV, as some stores do not have trade-in capabilities.
Stores without trade-ins: 'Twin Cities/St. Louis Park, MN', 'Beltway/Rockville, MD' [add more when discovered]
Current trade in values as of 11/29/11 from the CAG community (Thanks fortunado for compiling and editing list)
(11/29/11) - Added some new values today. I overheard someone say that all the games MC buys get shipped off to their buyer and then redistributed among the stores that lack certain titles. At my store they will take one copy per game, per console, per day, per person. So it may be possible to just spread trades of duplicate games out over the course of a few weeks.
(4/1/12) - RAGE Anarchy Edition not being accepted at some stores due to UPC being different from what they allow (even though it is the "better" version). YMMV on this if the employee will override.
To keep the wiki current, try to enter the date you obtained the value.
Modern Warfare console w/250 GB hard drive - $75 (12/7/11)
Alan Wake - $10 (12/26/11)
Alice: Madness Returns - $25 (03/11/12)
Apache:Air Assault - $20 (12/5/11)
Assassin's Creed - $2 (12/18/11)
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood - $20 (12/26/11)
Assassin's Creed: Revelations - $30 (mid-Sept '12)
Batman: Arkham Asylum - $7 (11/29/11)
Batman: Arkham City - $25 (3/4/12) (Possibly DEAD - rejected Trade in 4/5/2012)
Battlefield 3 - $25 (3/3/12)
Battlefield Bad Company 2 Limited Edition - $6 (12/18/11)
Battlefield Bad Company 2 Ultimate Edition - $7 (12/18/11)
Bioshock 2 - $7 (12/18/11)
Bodycount - $25 (4/1/12)
Brink - $2 (3/03/12) (DEAD - Memo sent to stores, notes in Gaming Dept.)
Bulletstorm - $17 (4/7/12)
Cabela's Dangerous Hunts 2011 - $15 (12/21/11)
Call of Juarez: The Cartel - $25 (12/29/11)
Captain America - $20 (3/25/12)
Cars 2 - $12 (11/29/11)
Castlevania: Lords of Shadow - $18 (12/19/11)
Catherine - $25 (12/18/11)
Child of Eden - $15 (12/11/11)
CoD Black Ops - $22 (11/30/11)
CoD Modern Warfare 2 - $10 (12/16/11)
CoD Modern Warfare 3 - $25 (4/6/12)
Crysis 2 - $25 (4/1/12)
Dark Souls - $27 (3/25/12)
De Blob 2 - $9 (3/24/12)
Dead Island - $28 (3/25/12)
Dead Rising 2 - $15 (12/18/11)
Dead Space 2 - $25 (4/1/12)
Deus Ex: Human Revolution - $27 (4/4/12)
Dirt 3 - $20 (3/25/12)
Dragon Age 2 - $20 (12/24/11)
Dragon Age Origins: Ultimate Edition - $17 (12/21/11)
Duke Nukem Forever - $4.50 (3/3/12)
Dungeon Siege III - $27 (03/12/12)
EA Sports MMA - $7 (12/11/11)
EA Active 2 - Not Accepted (3/16/12)
Enslaved: Odyssey - $16 (04/07/12)
F1 2010 - $18 (12/09/11)
Fable 3 - $10 (12/22/11)
Fallout: New Vegas - $10 (12/26/11)
F.E.A.R 2 - $5 (3/25/12)
F.E.A.R 3 - $25 (4/1/12)
Fifa Soccer 11 - $20 (12/19/11)
Fifa Soccer 12 - $30 (12/29/11)
Fifa Street - $25 (4/6/12)
Fight Night Champion - $25 (12/16/11)
Final Fantasy XIII - $10 (12/19/11)
Final Fantasy XIII-2 - $30 (4/5/12)
The First Templar - $25 (12/5/11)
Forza 4 - $30 (12/05/11)
Gears of War - $1 (4/5/2012)
Gears of War 3 - $30 (4/2/12)
Halo 3 - $2 (4/1/12)
Halo Reach - $15 (11/30/11)
Hasbro Family Game Night 3 - $18 (12/21/11)
Homefront - $2 (4/13/11)
Hunted: The Demon's Forge - $6.50 (4/6/12)
James Bond 007 Blood Stone - $11 (11/30/11)
Kinect Adventures - $7 (12/18/11)
Kinect Disneyland Adventures - $25 (12/19/11)
Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning - $30 (3/9/12)
Knights Contract - $20 (12/01/11)
L.A. Noire - $10 (3/03/12)
Left 4 Dead 2 - $6 (09/30/12)
Lost Planet 2 - $7 (11/29/11)
Madden NFL 11 - $15 (12/21/11)
Madden NFL 12 - $25 (12/05/11)
Major League Baseball 2K11 - $20 (12/18/11)
Marvel Super Hero Squad Comic Combat - $15 (3/3/12)
Marvel vs Capcom 3 - $25 (4/5/12)
Mass Effect 2 - $7 (4/5/12)
Mass Effect 3 - $7 (9/30/12)
Medal of Honor - $12 (4/5/2012)
Michael Jackson: The Experience - $20 (11/29/11)
Mindjack - $3 (4/7/12)
NBA 2K11 - $14 (12/19/11)
NBA 2K12 - $25 (11/29/11)
NBA Jam - $14 (12/26/11)
NCAA Football 11 - $20 (12/26/11)
NCAA Football 12 - $20 (12/05/11)
Need For Speed Hot Pursuit - $10 (11/30/11)
NeverDead - $30 (3/3/12)
NFS Shift 2: Unleashed - $20 (12/24/11)
NHL 2011 - $20 (12/01/11)
Ninety-Nine Nights 2 - $10 (11/30/11)
Operation Flashpoint: Red River - $28 (12/18/11)
Portal 2 - $27 (12/18/11)
Prototype 2 - $25 (06/20/12)
Rage - $27 (4/1/12)
R.U.S.E. - $7 (11/29/11)
Red Dead Redemption - $20 (12/01/11)
Red Dead Redemption: Undead Nightmare - $14 (12/10/11)
Red Faction Armageddon - $9 (4/6/12)
Rock Band 2 - $5 (12/18/11)
Rock Band 3 - $15 (12/26/11)
Saints Row 2 - $6 (12/18/11)
Saints Row: The Third - $24 (8/1/12)
Sesame Street: Once Upon a Monster - $20 (3/25/12)
The Sims 3 - $25 (3/5/12)
Skyrim - $30 (4/6/12)
Sniper Ghost Warrior - $12 (11/29/11)
Soul Calibur V - $25 (3/9/12)
Spider-Man Shattered Dimensions - $15 (11/29/11) Told no longer accepted on 360.
SSX - $24 (9/30/12)
Star Wars Force Unleashed II - $15 (12/18/11)
Street Fighter x Tekken - $30 (4/6/12)
Super Street Fighter IV - $11 (12/26/11)
Test Drive Unlimited 2 - $15 (12/10/11)
Thor - $25 (3/25/12)
Tiger Woods PGA Tour 12 - $17 (12/18/11)
Tiger Woods PGA Tour 13 - $25 (4/6/12)
Toy Story 3 - $10 (12/19/11)
Transformers: Dark of the Moon - $25 (4/1/12)
Transformers: War for Cybertron - $15 (4/1/12)
Tron: Evolution - $15 (12/26/11)
Two Worlds 2 - $25 (3/25/12)
UFC Undisputed 3 - $25 (3/9/12)
Vanquish - $18 (12/16/11)
Warhammer: Space Marine - $28 (4/1/12)
Witcher 2 - $30 (09/30/12)
WWE All Stars - $20 (12/09/11)
WWE Smackdown vs Raw 2011 - $20 (12/18/11)
X-Men Destiny - $20 (4/1/12)
Alice: Madness Returns - $17 (4/1/12)
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood - $12 (11/29/11)
Atelier Rorona: The Alchemist of Arland - $17 (12/26/11)
Batman: Arkham City - $25 (3/4/12) - (Possibly DEAD - rejected Trade in 4/5/2012)
Battlefield 3 - Standard Edition - $17 (9/30/12)
Battlefield Bad Company 2 Limited Edition - $6 (12/19/11)
Battlefield Bad Company 2 Ultimate Edition - $12 (12/19/11)
Bioshock 2 - $5 (12/19/11)
Bioshock 2 Collector's Edition - $7 (12/19/11)
Bodycount - $26 (4/1/12)
Brink - $25 (12/11/11) (DEAD - Memo sent to stores, notes in Gaming Dept.)
Brutal Legend - $5 (12/19/11)
Bulletstorm - $17 (4/5/12)
Call of Juarez: The Cartel - $12.50 (3/3/12)
Captain America - $20 (12/18/11)
Castlevania: Lords of Shadow - $10 (12/19/11)
Catherine - $25 (12/18/11)
Chronicles of Riddick: Assault on Dark Athena - $5 (1/31/12)
CoD: Black Ops - $23 (4/12/12)
CoD: Modern Warfare 2 - $7 (12/16/11)
CoD: Modern Warfare 3 - $25 (9/30/12)
Cross Edge - $6 (3/25/12)
Crysis 2 - $25 (03/20/12)
The Cursed Crusade - $15 (4/7/12)
Darkness II - $6 (09/30/12)
Dark Souls - $27 (4/1/12)
Dead Space - $5 (4/2/12)
Dead Island - $28 (4/1/12)
Dead Rising 2 - $17 (12/10/11)
Dead Space 2 - $17 (3/20/12)
Deus EX - $25 (12/01/11)
Dirt 3 - $10 (4/6/12)
Dragon Age 2 - $22 (12/01/11)
Duke Nukem Forever - $15 (12/19/11)
Dungeon Siege III - $27 (12/03/11)
Enslaved: Odyssey - $6 (12/19/11)
F1 2010 - $17 (11/29/11)
Fallout 3 - $6 (4/2/12)
F.E.A.R. 3 - $22 (4/4/12)
The Fight: Lights Out - $12 (11/29/11)
Fifa Soccer 11 - $20 (12/19/11)
Fifa Street - $25 (4/6/12)
Fight Night Champion - $17 (12/16/11)
Final Fantasy XIII - $10 (4/1/12)
Final Fantasy XIII-2 - $30 (4/5/12)
God of War III - $5 (12/26/11)
God of War Origins Collection - $25 (3/3/12)
Gran Turismo 5 - $5 (9/30/12)
Homefront - $2 (4/13/12)
Hunted: The Demon's Forge - $25 (12/24/11)
Infamous - $8 (12/19/11)
Infamous 2 - $24 (12/03/11)
Just Cause 2 - $10 (12/03/11)
Killzone 2 - $7 (12/19/11)
Killzone 3 - $25 (4/1/12)
Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning - $30 (3/9/12)
King of Fighters XII - $9 (4/4/12)
King of Fighters XIII - $20 (4/4/12)
L.A. Noire - $10 (3/3/12)
LEGO Star Wars III: The Clone Wars - $18 (12/10/11)
The Lord of the Rings: Aragorn's Quest - $14 (11/30/11)
Madden NFL 11 - $7.50 (4/1/12)
Mafia II - $8 (12/03/11)
Major League Baseball 2K11 - $22 (12/16/11)
Marvel vs Capcom 3 - $25 (4/4/12)
Mass Effect 2 - $7 (4/6/12)
Mass Effect 3 - $7 (9/30/12)
MLB The Show '11 - $9 (4/12/12)
MLB The Show '12 - $30 (3/7/12)
Mindjack - $3 (4/12/12)
Naruto Ultimate Ninja Storm 2 - $17 (12/05/11)
NBA 2K11 - $17 (12/11/11)
NBA Jam - $15 (12/09/11)
NCAA Football 11 - $10 (4/1/12)
NeverDead - $30 (3/3/12)
NFS Shift 2: Unleashed - $23 (12/03/11)
NFS The Run - $11 (09/30/12)
NHL 2011 - $22 (12/11/11)
Operation Flashpoint: Red River - $28 (3/3/12)
Portal 2 - $13.50 (3/20/12)
Prince of Persia Trilogy - $15 (12/03/12)
RAGE - $25 (3/15/12)
Red Dead Redemption - $12 (4/2/12)
Resistance 3 - $12 (4/12/12)
Rock Band 3 - $5 (12/19/11)
Saints Row The Third - $30 (2/8/12)
Shift 2 - $23 (12/3/11)
The Sims 3 - $23 (12/26/11)
Skyrim - $23 (9/30/12)
SOCOM 4 - $27 (4/1/12)
Soul Calibur V - $25 (3/9/12)
Spider-Man: Shattered Dimensions - $10 (11/29/11)
Sports Champion - $6 (12/19/11)
SSX - $25 (3/9/12)
Starhawk - $30 (06/20/12)
Star Ocean: The Last Hope International - $6 (12/03/11)
Star Wars Force Unleashed II - $7.50 (1/31/12)
Start the Party - $12 (12/19/11)
Street Fighter x Tekken - $25 (4/6/12)
Super Street Fighter IV - $10 (12/26/11)
The Lord of the Rings Aragorn's Quest - $14 (11/30/11)
Thor - $25 (4/1/12)
Tiger Woods PGA Tour '13 - $25 (4/6/12)
Tomb Raider Trilogy - $8 (12/18/11)
Transformers: Dark of the Moon - $27 (12/18/11)
Transformers: War for Cybertron - $15 (3/16/12)
Tron: Evolution - $12 (12/19/11)
TV Superstars - $5 (12/19/11)
Twisted Metal - $30 (4/6/12)
Two Worlds 2 - $9 (3/28/12)
UFC Undisputed 3 - $25 (3/9/12)
Uncharted 2 - $12 (4/2/12)
Uncharted 3 - $22 (09/30/12)
Vanquish - $14 (4/2/12)
Warriors Legend of Troy - $22 (12/16/11)
White Knight Chronicles 1 - $4 (09/30/12)
WWE All Stars - $23 (12/09/11)
WWE Smackdown vs Raw 2011 - $20 (11/29/11)
Conduit 2 - $22 (12/01/11)
De Blob 2 - $12 (12/14/11)
Donkey Kong Country Returns - $25 (11/29/11)
Dood's Big Adventure - $4 (12/16/11)
Epic Mickey - $22 (11/29/11)
Fortune Street - $25 (3/3/12)
Goldeneye - $15 (11/29/11)
Just Dance: Summer Party - $20 (12/26/11)
Just Dance 3 - $25 (11/29/11)
Kirby's Epic Yarn - $25 (4/6/12)
Kirby Return To Dreamland - $25 (11/29/11)
Lego Star Wars: The Complete Saga - $6 (4/1/12)
Madden NFL 11 - $10 (11/29/11)
Madworld - $2 (1/31/12)
Mario Party 9 - $25 (6/20/12)
Mario & Sonic: London Olympic Games - $25 (3/3/12)
Monopoly Streets - $18 (11/29/11)
New Super Mario Bros. - $25 (11/29/11)
Poke Park 2 - $25 (4/6/12)
Rhythm Heaven Fever - $25 (3/9/12)
Super Monkey Ball: Banana Blitz (4/1/12)
The Price is Right 2010 - $10 (11/29/11)
Top Spin 4 - $13 (11/29/11)
Virtua Tennis 4 - $20 (12/24/11)
Wii Party - $15 (11/29/11)
Wipeout - $12 (1/31/11)
WWE Smackdown vs Raw 2011 - $20 (3/3/12)
Zelda: Skyward Sword - $25 (6/20/12)
Zelda: Twilight Princess - $12 (4/2/12)
Brain Age - $3 (4/1/12)
Castlevania: Portrait of Ruin - $6 (4/1/12)
Dragon Ball Z: Attack of the Saiyans - $13 (12/09/11)
Dragon Quest IX: Sentinels of the Starry Skies - $12 (12/26/11)
Dragon Quest Monsters: Joker 2 - $15 (11/29/11)
Final Fantasy: The 4 Heroes of Light - $8 (12/26/11)
Kingdom Hearts Re:Coded - $8 (4/1/12)
Kirby Mass Attack - $15 (11/29/11)
LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean - $12 (11/29/11)
Mario vs Donkey Kong: Mini-Land Mayhem - $10 (11/29/11)
Overlord Minions - $6 (11/29/11)
Pokemon White, Black or Platinum - $15 (3/3/12)
Puzzle Quest: Galactrix - $2 (4/1/12)
Bust a Move Universe - $10 (12/26/11)
Combat of Giant Dinosaurs - $12 (1/31/12)
Kid Icarus - $15 (6/20/12)
Madden NFL Football 3DS - $12 (1/31/12)
Mario Kart 7 - $15 (4/6/12)
Metal Gear Solid Snake Eater - $15 (06/20/12)
Nintendogs: French Bulldog & New Friends - $12 (1/31/12)
Nintendogs: Golden Retriever - $12 (1/31/12)
Nintendogs: Toy Poodle & New Friends - $12 (1/31/12)
Pilotwings Resort - $12 (4/1/12)
The Sims 3 - $14 (12/26/11)
Starfox 64 3DS - $15 (11/29/11)
Steel Diver - $12 (1/31/12)
Super Mario 3D Land - $15 (3/3/12)
Lord of Arcana - $10 (12/19/11)
Persona 2: Innocent Sin - $15 (12/16/11)
http://www.microcenter.com/storefronts/gaming/used.html
YMMV, as some stores do not have trade-in capabilities.
Stores without trade-ins: 'Twin Cities/St. Louis Park, MN', 'Beltway/Rockville, MD' [add more when discovered]
Current trade in values as of 11/29/11 from the CAG community (Thanks fortunado for compiling and editing list)
(11/29/11) - Added some new values today. I overheard someone say that all the games MC buys get shipped off to their buyer and then redistributed among the stores that lack certain titles. At my store they will take one copy per game, per console, per day, per person. So it may be possible to just spread trades of duplicate games out over the course of a few weeks.
(4/1/12) - RAGE Anarchy Edition not being accepted at some stores due to UPC being different from what they allow (even though it is the "better" version). YMMV on this if the employee will override.
To keep the wiki current, try to enter the date you obtained the value.















































































































































































































































































































Last edited by a moderator: