[quote name='MSI Magus']Heres the thing. Fiancee is only uncomfortable with it because she thinks other people will snub their nose at it. And I have been compromising, we are spending way more then I wanted to, having it in a way I dont want to and inviting people I dont want to.
[/QUOTE]
Tough, its a wedding...its not for you, really, its for her...to show off, her moment in the sun thats really what weddings all come down to. Every girl wants to grow up (well most of em) to be a bride or a princess...since most of em wont make the latter, they opt for the former so just nod and give her waht she wants.
The PROBLEM will be if you can't afford what she wants.....remember, its one day and its all over so fast you have to be comfortable with what you're spending your money on.
I am guessing that since you are doing this as a pot-luck you really aren't expecting to make out at your wedding, right? ie: Most of the weddings I go to require a suit and tie and $200 checks (which traditionally is to cover the cost of the meal and give a little something to the bride and groom...which you wont get if people are bringing their own Cole Slaw and Baked Beans). NOte I've been to weddings where the norm was more like $1000, but they were pretty ethnic affairs, so it varies by region to region and community by community, not sure where you fall into the mix.
Her mom has taken shot after shot after shot at me and iv just taken them all on the chin to keep things civil......trust me I understand how important this day is. Just figured maybe this could be the one thing she compromised on....but still seems everyones against it so I guess ill chalk it up to a bad idea.
My big concession on my wedding day? Carrots. Seriously, I got Carrots. They were planning the meal and my wife and my mother decided on Mixed Vegetables...I said "Nope, I want carrots". My wife and mother politely informed me that some people might not LIKE carrots, and I calmly replied "Look, I haven't asked for shit in this thing....but I'm getting

ing carrots, understand? If people dont LIKE carrots they can eat the potatos or the salad or the OTHER 800 items we are feeding them, but on my plate...there will be carrots". And that was that
I might still use it in the sense of ordering like 15 pizzas and having them as a side. Like since everyone is bringing their fav dish mine is pizza so instead of ordering like 60 of them and having them be the main course ill just order like 10-15 and its enough everyone can get a slice? Does that sound more appropriate?
For a Jug-Band weddin' held in a trailer park, sure!
To the guy that said mohawk at a wedding? Hehe you will probally love our cake. We are trying to find someone to make us a Katamari cake. The prince will be rolling a heart shaped ball and the bride and groom and a bunch of frosting will have been rolled up.
Its nice to see you're taking this whole thing seriously.....I give you 3 years, tops.
I hope you at least inform the people you are inviting that its a Pot Luck wedding and let them know to not wear a suit.
FOLLOUP AFTER SOUNDING LIKE A DICK ABOVE:
You gotta remember a wedding is supposed to be a once-in-a-lifetime event, don't make it a SuperBowl party......don't make it a kegger......its kinda supposed to be you and your wife showing off to your family and friends who are supposed to bring you nice gifts as a thank-you (money or otherwise) and go from there. I've been to weddings where the spouses got trashed, and it was pretty embarassing. I've been to ones where the guys got too wild or the girls got too slutty, and those were pretty embarassing too.....
But I digresss, in the end: Give her what she wants, so long as she is prepared to eat the cost along with you, and STFU. Its not about you, its about her.....