[quote name='GhostShark']So far, I am enjoying the show, but it does have some major flaws that BSG didn't have. I think the show tries to do too much, for example, the show appears to be more about the Graystones than anybody else. All the stuff with the Adamas just seems like filler within each episode that could easily be excluded.[/QUOTE]
I was a fan of BSG, and I felt like I gave Caprica a pretty even break. I didn't expect it to be BSG, and I didn't care if they referred to "canon" at all. I just wanted an intelligent, interesting TV show, and they didn't have that for a whole bunch of reasons.
The biggest point is the one you raised: they never connected the Greystones and Adamas. Ever. Nor did they give us much of a reason to be interested in either family (IMO, I realize that may be a contentious point).
Furthermore, the tone of the show was shrill in a hand-wringing, teen anxiety kind of way. Maybe that came out of wanting to promote the show using Zoe, but it didn't work. To me, the uneven, harried tone made other things hard to follow, like the religion. Ugh, the religion.
And there's the larger thematic disappointment that isn't exactly about "respecting" the BSG canon, or wanting the show to be more BSG-like. It's just the desire to see something of The Cycle in all this, to see a sliver of that show up in Caprica. Maybe it was there, but it wasn't much.
Overall, not a good show. Sorry to say it, but it wasn't good. SciFi gave them a fair shot, I thought: the show looked like they had a decent budget, and they had a decent cast. And the writers/producers weren't anything to sneeze at, I just think they needed more time to figure out what the hell they wanted to do, and instead of thinking it through, they just started shooting episodes so they could release with some of the BSG finale momentum still around.
I certainly don't think less of the people involved because of Caprica, I just think they needed a plan and didn't have one.