[quote name='Veronica Mars']So, Should I Return it and buy it somewhere else?
They told me that GS.com/EB.com sometimes sends out "Gutted games" also.
I don't know if it's true.
Edit: No signs of being played, I may sound dumb, but can you play a game and it still shows no signs of being used? (Scratches, Dust, ETC)? It looks new, so scratches or anything.[/quote]
Well, I didn't wanna also point out what others have, that many GS stores let their employees try out the opened/gut copy games, so your 'opened but never played' gut copy may well have been passed around quite a bit by people who treated it gently.
Totally up to you to decide if you wanna play it or return it, but if it were me, I'd return it and try to find a sealed copy. That's just me though.