[quote name='primetime']And in my opinion Eli isn't top 10 yet. Off the top of my head, in no definite order I could list Manning, Brady, Palmer, Favre-Brees, Hasselbeck, McNabb, Bulger-Roethlisberger, Romo, Garrard. Then he's probably in a jumble with guys like Cutler, Leinart, Rivers, Garcia, etc. It seems to me like he gets down when he's throwing picks and such, but I like Eli's attitude for the most part.[/quote]
I think Eli is better than McNabb (now) and Garrard... maybe Bulger too. I'd take any of the others over him though (well, except Favre since he is not long for the league). I guess I'd take Romo even though he hasn't proven he can win in the playoffs - I think he is a better football player and will probably have a beter career than Eli.