I was pretty happy with the find at my local Sears. This was YESTERDAY. It didn't even look like they had been touched.
As others have stated, the prices on the games were completely wrong, and I had to have an associate scan them. He thought I was crazy until the prices came up and then went through all the phases "How did he know more than me?"
Of course, he became incredibly disenheartened as I took these games.
Here's what I bought
Super Smash Brothers Brawl, Wii - 9.97
Zelda Skyward Sword, Wii - 29.97
Mario Sports Mix, Wii - 9.97
Star Fox 64 3DS, 3DS - 9.99 x2
Tiger Woods PGA Tour 12, PS3 - 9.97
Halo Reach, 360 - 9.97
Modern Warfare 3, Wii - 9.97 x2 (got an extra copy for my bro)
Portal 2, for both 360 and PS3 was 9.97 each. I would remind you that Gamestop is currently taking 50% bonus credit on it, giving it a TIV of $19.50. I plan on going back and picking up a few copies if they are still there.
Halo Reach is also in the %50 TIV and is currently getting 25.50
I had him scan other prices. Pokemon Rumble Blast was still full price, as were all the Lego games (Pirates, Star Wars, etc. for all systems) Skyrim, Borderlands 2, Most Mario games, all new 3DS games, all Vita games (broke my heart).
Those games were STILL FULL PRICE. Definetly YMMV!
The PS3 Move Bundle was not $25, or even $50, but firm at full price, $99 (REALLY disenheartening), I was hoping for that to be my biggest score.
As a noob, this is really my first big buy from CAG, and i'm very pleased.
I've got an extra copy of Star Fox i'm willing to trade (would love a copy of ANY pokemon game someone picked up from this deal

), but am interested in anything. PM if interested.
That's not all though.
After paying, I got a bunch of coupons. One was a $5 off any $50 purchase instore (excludes gaming HARDWARE). I'm assuming it still works for video games. The other was a $5 off any $50 electronics purchase (2 cannot be combined). I plan on going back and getting 2 more $50 purchases whilst able. I would recommend you guys jump on this if you find something worthy.