Official User Feedback/Rating Topic [Part 1]

Status
Not open for further replies.
Who did you trade with? King Bahamut
What did you get? Lunar 2 and Star Ocean
What did you give? SMB4, Zelda Masterquest, Cash
How long did the deal take? About week and a half
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? Priority Mail w/DC
Shipping Price (If not included)? $4.30
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? N/A
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Games were in great condition and arrived quickly. Packaging could have been somewhat better, but thanks!
 
Who did you trade with? drfrielgood
What did you get? Mace Griffin Bounty Hunter
What did you give? Stretch Panic
How long did the deal take? A weekend
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yup
Shipping Method Used? Shipped Media first, but he shipped First Class
Shipping Price (If not included)? $1.42
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? N/A
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Good trade, great trader, thank you for the game.
 
Who did you trade with? CaseyRyback
What did you get? Some PC Games
What did you give? Halo, Clone Wars/Tetris, Tomb Raider AoD
How long did the deal take? A couple weeks to negotiate.
Were they friendly? Yep
Easy to work with? Sure.
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? yesiree
Shipping Method Used? Priority Mail
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? We were able to negotiate a fair trade. The reason it took so long was more me trying to figure out what I wanted and him trying to figure out what he had. But we worked it out and once finalized things were shipped next day and arrived in two more.
 
Who did you trade with? dragonlordfrodo
What did you get? ninja gaiden (xbox)
What did you give? splinter cell pandora tomorrow (xbox)
How long did the deal take? a week
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? definately
Shipping Method Used?
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? great condition of game and was willing to ship first since he had no feedback. good trader.
 
Who did you trade with? BankyHax
What did you get? 8 NES games
What did you give? $$
How long did the deal take? A couple of days for transaction
Were they friendly? Yup
Easy to work with? Yup
Quick to respond? Part yes, part no
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? Media(?)
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? PayPal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Would have liked to have been informed about when it was sent, but I was confused about when he went on vacation. Thank you for the games, excellent condition.
 
Who did you trade with? Teremei
What did you get? SSX3
What did you give? Cash
How long did the deal take? 6 days
Were they friendly? YES
Easy to work with? YES
Quick to respond? YES
Would you deal with them again? YES
Shipping Method Used? USPS
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Paypal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Game is in great condition, just as described, very friendly.
 
Who did you trade with? magilacudy
What did you get? 15 bucks code off EA Store
What did you give? my gratitude
How long did the deal take? umm instant (in person decision)
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? yes
Shipping Method Used? n/a
Shipping Price (If not included)? n/a
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? n/a
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10/10
Additional Comments? nice guy known to be a good trader
 
Who did you trade with? Siamesellama
What did you get? ICO
What did you give? Cash
How long did the deal take? 6 days
Were they friendly? YES
Easy to work with? YES
Quick to respond? YES
Would you deal with them again? YES
Shipping Method Used? USPS
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Paypal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Game is in better condition I thought it would be. Awesome trade.
 
Who did you trade with? redgopher
What did you get? supposed to get MM 8, Oddworld: Abe's Odyssey + strat guide
What did you give? PN03 and their shipping
How long did the deal take? indefinite, he did not send
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? somewhat
Would you deal with them again? god no
Shipping Method Used? UPS, then USPS
Shipping Price (If not included)? $4, and i payed for theirs also
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 0/10
Additional Comments? redgopher would not even send my part of the trade back to me. i understand that he bought the PN03 before mine arrived to him, but he could have at least sent it back. I even had $5 with it with which he could have returned it. Horrible experience.
 
Who did you trade with? SpaceManSpiff
What did you get? Cash
What did you give? ICO
How long did the deal take? 6 days
Were they friendly? YES
Easy to work with? YES
Quick to respond? YES
Would you deal with them again? YES
Shipping Method Used? USPS
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Paypal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Thanks man!
 
Who did you trade with? Radjago
What did you get? Advance Wars (GBA)
What did you give? $18usd
How long did the deal take? 1 week
Were they friendly? extremely
Easy to work with? Top Notch
Quick to respond? very quick
Would you deal with them again? definitely
Shipping Method Used? usps
Shipping Price (If not included)? included
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? paypal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Radjago is an awesome seller. I appreciated the fact he checked up to see if I recieved the game a-ok.
 
I traded with: SpaceManSpiff
I gave: SSX 3 mint complete PS2
I got: $21 shipped
It took: About 2 days negotiating
Shiping method: First Class

Was wonderful, 10/10, quick, no hassle. Would deal again. (sorry I just feel some of those feilds are not important, hopefully my condensed version does not upset anyone)
 
Who did you trade with? jkam
What did you get? Arc the Lad: Twilight of the Spirits (PS2) (new)
What did you give? Crazy Taxi (GC) (new)
How long did the deal take? About a week
Were they friendly? Very
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? USPS First Class
Shipping Price (If not included)? $1.85 ship + package cost
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? If only all on-line business transactions could be this quick and easy (and cheap :D )
 
Who did you trade with? starky27
What did you get? Crazy Taxi (GC) (new)
What did you give? Arc the Lad: Twilight of the Spirits (PS2) (new)
How long did the deal take? About a week
Were they friendly? Very
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? USPS First Class
Shipping Price (If not included)? $2.38
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? He sent the game first (because of feedback) with no problems. Got the game super quick. Great communication. A+ Trader.
 
Who did you trade with? sm04as
What did you get? Star wars/tetris bundle
What did you give? Total Immersion Racing
How long did the deal take? about a week
Were they friendly? yup
Easy to work with?yup
Quick to respond?yup
Would you deal with them again?yup
Shipping Method Used? media
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10/10
Additional Comments?[/quote] thanks! he is very understandable!
 
Who did you trade with? punqsux
What did you get? Fatal Frame II
What did you give? Simoleans ^^
How long did the deal take? About a week
Were they friendly? Very
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? USPS First Class
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? ^^
 
Who did you trade with? ZForce
What did you get? Beyond Good & Evil strategy guide
What did you give? Ratchet & Clank: GC strategy guide
How long did the deal take? About a week
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? Media mail
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Smooth transaction :D
 
Who Did You Trade With? mr. anderson
What Did You Get? LOTR: ROTK (ps2 ver)
What Did You Give? Rygar and Xenosaga
How long did the deal take? His part: 3 days My part:About a week and a half :oops:
Were They Friendly? Yep
Easy To Work With? yep
Quick to Respond? Yes
Would You Deal With Them Again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? USPS
Overall Experience (Out of 10)?10
Additional Comments? Sorry bout those boxes, but at least the CD's were in mint condition
 
Who did you trade with? MetroidKiller9
What did you get? Splinter Cell Pandora Tomorrow
What did you give? Ninja Gaiden
How long did the deal take? About a week
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? Regular Mail
Shipping Price (If not included)? I think I used like 3 stamps
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? N/A
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Great Trader.
 
Who did you trade with? spookyhurst
What did you get? Ratchet and Clank 2 Strategy Guide
What did you give? Beyond Good and Evil Strategy Guide
How long did the deal take? Around 3 days
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Already Have
Shipping Method Used? Media mail
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Overall experience rating 10 out of 10
Additional Comments? Good transaction
 
Who did you trade with? Dane
What did you get? Super Mario Sunshine
What did you give? $17
How long did the deal take? A little less than 2 weeks
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? USPS
Shipping Price (If not included)? Included
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? USPS Money order
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? My money order took a long time, which caused the deal to drag a little. He shipped quickly
 
Who did you trade with? starman9000
What did you get? Boktai (GBA) and Zelda Oracle of Ages (GBC)
What did you give? James and the Giant Peach DVD, Waking Life DVD, a few OXM demo discs, a Gamecube Memory card 59, and $6.00
How long did the deal take? Overall...maybe 5-6 days...shipping was like 2!
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes. No doubt about it.
Shipping Method Used? USPS Priority Mail
Shipping Price (If not included)? $3.85 +.45 for delivery conf.
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Trade, and I paid part in Paypal.
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Excellent trader! Highly recommended, easy to work with!
 
Who did you trade with? JimmieMac
What did you get? Hitman 2 (GC Sealed)
What did you give? Tony Hawk Underground (PS2 Used)
How long did the deal take? 4 days
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Sure thing.
Shipping Method Used? Mail
Shipping Price (If not included)? $3
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? N/A
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Super quick and easy transaction.
 
Who did you trade with? CaseyRyback
What did you get? Madden '96 (snes)
What did you give? nothing
How long did the deal take? a week
Were they friendly? he just gave it to me!
Easy to work with? oh yeah
Quick to respond? you bet
Would you deal with them again? would love to
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Awesome guy. I have been looking for this game ever since i found my snes again
 
Who did you trade with?Mustang O-Line 75
What did you get? nothing
What did you give? Madden 96
How long did the deal take? week
Were they friendly? yea
Easy to work with? yea
Quick to respond? yea
Would you deal with them again? yea
Shipping Method Used?
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? It cost me like 2 bucks out of pocket. I know how long it took to compile the trading list (I did 4 pages and it took like 30 or so minutes and it was not even near correct) and wanted to show my appreciation.
 
Who did you trade with? jousley
What did you get? $12
What did you give? Eternal Darkness
How long did the deal take? A week.
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? Media Mail
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Paypal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Nope.
 
Who did you trade with? doraemonkerpal
What did you get? KOF: Dream Match 1999 & Soul Calibur (Both DC)
What did you give? Devil May Cry 2
How long did the deal take? About a week
Were they friendly? Yes yes
Easy to work with? Quite so
Quick to respond? Like greased lightning on steroids
Would you deal with them again? most def
Shipping Method Used? UPS
Shipping Price (If not included)? -
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Great transaction, quick replies, great packaging. Only complaint was that there were a few fingerprints on the discs. But it was quickly fixed by a damp cloth.
 
Who did you trade with? sm04as
What did you get? Phantasy Star Collection SEALED + 007 Nightfire (xbox) SEALED
What did you give? Mario Golf (N64) MINT complete + $12
How long did the deal take? 7 days
Were they great? YES YES YES
Shipping Method Used? PRIORITY both of us
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10/10
Additional Comments? Very fun person to trade and talk with.
 
Who did you trade with? SpaceManSpiff
What did you get? Muh-nee
What did you give? Culdcept, Devil May Cry and Suikoden
How long did the deal take? Negotiations and payment within 12 hours.
Were they friendly? Si
Easy to work with? Da
Quick to respond? Comparable to a speeding bullet
Would you deal with them again? Most def
Shipping Method Used? Paypal :D
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Easy negotiations, friendly guy, fast payment. No hassles here, A+ all the way.
 
Who did you trade with? swetooth9
What did you get? Cash
What did you give? Dynasty Warriors instuction Book
How long did the deal take? Couple days
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yup
Would you deal with them again? Sure
Shipping Method Used? Regular mail
Shipping Price (If not included)? .83
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments?
 
Who did you trade with? beerguy691
What did you get? cash
What did you give? mario sunshine
How long did the deal take? About a week
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? Regular Mail
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? N/A
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Great Trader.
 
Who did you trade with? livetnediser
What did you get? Time Crisis 2 w/gun, Sonic Mega Collection, $30
What did you give? RE: CV (GC), RE: Dead Aim, Dino Crisis 3, RE: CV (PS2)
How long did the deal take? week
Were they friendly? yup
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? media mail
Shipping Price (If not included)? $1.85 ship + package cost
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? easy and quick
 
Who did you trade with? sm04as
What did you get? Stretch Panic
What did you give? Blowout
How long did the deal take? week
Were they friendly? yup
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? media mail
Shipping Price (If not included)? $1.85 ship + package cost
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? easy and quick
 
Who did you trade with? drfrielgood
What did you get? Mace Griffin
What did you give? Stretch Panic
How long did the deal take? week
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? media mail
Shipping Price (If not included)? $1.52
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Got it quickly, nice and minty. Thanks for the game!
 
Who did you trade with? Mr_hockey66
What did you get? Dynasty Warriors instuction Book
What did you give? 2.00
How long did the deal take? Couple days
Were they friendly? Very friendly
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yup
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? Paypal
Shipping Price (If not included)? N/A
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Paypal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments?
this guy is a good trader w/ good communication skills :D
 
Who did you trade with? Sailor Chrono
What did you get? Ca$h
What did you give? Fatal Frame II
How long did the deal take? about a day for her to get the $ to send me
Were they friendly? yepp!
Easy to work with? mmhmm
Quick to respond? Yup
Would you deal with them again? of course
Shipping Method Used? usps
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Paypal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10000000000000000000000000000000
Additional Comments? you shold open this game and play it ^^
 
Who did you trade with? sm04as
What did you get? $4
What did you give? SEGA Triple Score
How long did the deal take? 3 days
Were they friendly? yup
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? this is my 2nd trade and i see no reason to stop
Shipping Method Used? first class
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? again, lightening fast payment! he send on the 30th and i got it on the 3rd!! and there was a sunday in there too! shipped it out this morning, hope u like it!
 
Who did you trade with? jshorr
What did you get? Viewtiful Joe penny strategy guide
What did you give? Manhunt penny strategy guide
How long did the deal take? I sent on April 23rd, I received on May 3rd, so 10 days total.
Were they friendly? Absolutely.
Easy to work with? Beyond easy.
Quick to respond? Near instant replies to PMs!
Would you deal with them again? I hope to!
Shipping Method Used? USPS
Shipping Price (If not included)? -
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? -
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? My first trade on CAG and it was a great experience thanks to a friendly and easy to work with fellow CAGer.
 
Who did you trade with? Theeternal
What did you get? samurai showdown, castlevania bloodlines, $
What did you give? Marvel vs. capcom 2 for ps2
How long did the deal take? week
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? yes
Shipping Method Used? first class with d/c
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? great trader A+
 
Who did you trade with? jkam
What did you get? sonic 3 nba jam ff origins star wars starfighter ,etc.
What did you give? shinobi,castlevania, guide and $
How long did the deal take? week
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? yes
Shipping Method Used? first class with d/c
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? great trader!!!
 
Who did you trade with? JOEBOO
What did you get? Castlevania: LOI (New Sealed) Shinobi (New Sealed) Zelda Ocarina Of Time Srat Guide $2
What did you give? Virtua Racing 32x, Star Wars 32x, Sonic 3, NHL 96, NBA Jam (Genesis), Final Fantasy Origins (New Sealed), Star Wars Starfighter
How long did the deal take? Week or so
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Sure Thing
Shipping Method Used? First Class
Shipping Price (If not included)? About $5
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? It took a little while to work out a deal... but JOEBOO was cool the whole time. Even when I mis-interpreted what he was saying in one PM. Would definitely deal with again. A+ Trader. Thanks again!
 
Who did you trade with? flamegames
What did you get? earthbound
What did you give? medal of honor: rising sun (xbox) and xbox controller
How long did the deal take? a week
Were they friendly? very
Easy to work with? very
Quick to respond? very
Would you deal with them again? definately
Shipping Method Used?
Shipping Price (If not included)?
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? game in excellent condition, easy negotiations, he shipped first. great trader.
 
Who did you trade with? O.D.D.
What did you get? WWF TCL DVD
What did you give? UFC Tapout 2
How long did the deal take? a week
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? yes
Shipping Method Used? mail
Shipping Price (If not included)? N/A
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? N/A
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? It rubs the lotion on it's skin or else it gets the hose again.
 
Who did you trade with? JimmieMac
What did you get? UFC Tapout 2
What did you give? WWF TLC DVD
How long did the deal take? a week
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yes
Would you deal with them again? yes
Shipping Method Used? first-class
Shipping Price (If not included)? N/A
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? N/A
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Great trader....a little weird but still a great trader.
 
Who did you trade with? doraemonkerpal
What did you get? A Dreamcast and Arc the Lad Collection
What did you give? FF VII, FFVIII and FF XI
How long did the deal take? About a week
Were they friendly? Very
Easy to work with? You betcha
Quick to respond? Yup
Would you deal with them again? I hope I can someday
Shipping Method Used? I used USPS, he used UPS
Shipping Price (If not included)? $10
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? n/a
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? I'll give him a 10 because he's such a good guy. :)
Additional Comments? nah.
 
Who did you trade with? Namelessloser
What did you get? Money
What did you give? .Hack part three
How long did the deal take? couple of days
Were they friendly? yes
Easy to work with? yes
Quick to respond? yup
Would you deal with them again? sure ynot
Shipping Method Used? media mail
Shipping Price (If not included)? 1.42
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? paypal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? Good deal. I helped out a fellow CAGer get something they didn't have. I feel good, He feels good. Musta been good!
 
Who did you trade with? secretvampire
What did you get? $20
What did you give? 1 Year Xbox sub
How long did the deal take? 10 hours
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? Yes
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? E-mail
Shipping Price (If not included)? 0
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Buy
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? No
 
Who did you trade with? -Never4ever
What did you get? RE: Dead Aim, SP 5 SE
What did you give? RS6, Stretch Panic
How long did the deal take? Week
Were they friendly? Yes
Easy to work with? Yes
Quick to respond? No (internet down)
Would you deal with them again? Yes
Shipping Method Used? Media
Shipping Price (If not included)? 0
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)?
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 9
Additional Comments? No
 
Who did you trade with? Admiral Ackbar
What did you get? Eternal Darkness (gamecube) New
What did you give? $12
How long did the deal take? less than a week
Were they friendly? VERY
Easy to work with? Extremely
Quick to respond? lightning fast
Would you deal with them again? any day
Shipping Method Used? USPS
Shipping Price (If not included)? Included
Payment Method (If Buy/Sell)? Paypal
Overall experience rating (Out of 10)? 10
Additional Comments? The Admiral went out of his way to pick this game up for me. I am very grateful. Thanks again!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
bread's done
Back
Top