Well, since I just barely missed this deal yesterday, I figured I'd hit up the local store. They did have Rygar, but it rang up at 11.99 for a new copy (or they also had pre-played for 12.99!). I just checked ebgames.com and Rygar is available again.....but for 20.99. Oh well.
On a side note, I checked Culdcept based on the other posts and was actually able to get that for the 2.99. It was the last copy so was a display item, but I can handle that for the price. Sticker price on both games was still 19.99.