[quote name='FriskyTanuki']I'm looking for details, not the fanboy answer "because it's better." I want to know why the game wants to move the kicking cursor on punts and kickoffs, why I can only have one hot route change to my play and my running back can't change the direction of his run, why the QB runs like the guys in Virtua Tennis and not more naturally like in Madden, and why every player is skinny (like they're wearing girdles or something) when offensive/defensive lineman are usually fat? I'd rather use the A button to switch defensive player so it's easier to tackle. I don't get why I have to charge up my running backs and receivers just to have them run as fast as possible.
I'd still have to say that Madden 05 is better than NFL 2K5, but it's close.[/QUOTE] Madden is awful is just about every way (both the games and the man :lol: ). So, I don't see how you could even really compare them.