[quote name='Paco']A three year warranty on only one problem when there is still so many other problems is still crap. They did it simply to avoid the 2+ billion dollar lawsuit that was incoming and was going to kick their ass. There was no way Microsoft would win that lawsuit.
Type in 360 scratches discs in google and you get almost a million different items on it.
"Almost at the same time the Xbox 360 was released in late 2005, customers began reporting rounded scratches found on discs used in their Xbox 360 consoles. Almost two years later, in February 2007, the website "The Llamma's Adventures" investigated the matter and concluded that some Xbox 360 drives lack a mechanism to secure the disc solidly in place.
[35] Tilting or moving consoles with these drives, when operating with a disc spinning inside, can potentially cause damage to the disc, in some cases rendering the disc unusable.
[36] One side of the disc can also be scratched by the disc tray if it malfunctions by closing with the disc in an odd position."
Oh yeah this happens even when the system isn't moved. It just seems to randomly scratch them for no reason. It's just that any sort of wobble on the 360 when playing a game will lascerate the thing to hell. The fact that it will scratch discs even without movement makes it a huge WTF.
The E74 was almost unheard of until the NXE which lead many people to believe it was a reprogrammed RRoD to make sure people wouldn't be able to claim warranty. Though it does sound crazy, I would not put it past Microsoft to do something that shady. Some people say that the NXE makes the 360 work harder on the interface or whatever. Who knows what it really is but still it's something that is incredibly shady.
The fact that the original console warranty was 90 days then bumped up to a year and finally up to three years is insanely suspect. Sounds like they keep bumping up the warranty each time they're on the verge of getting class action lawsuit and they know that they will never win on those, especially in Europe where they already have many losses in anti trust lawsuits.[/QUOTE]
The disc scratching situation. The only way it occurs is from idiots and kids moving the system while the disc is spinning or if the disc was not properly put in the disc tray to begin with. Personally, I have had three different Xbox 360's since the launch of the Xbox 360 and I have never had the system scratch a disc. If Blu-rays could scratch, you would probably see the same thing online because of idiots moving their PS3 while the disc is spinning. Hence, why other systems had similiar issues in the past i.e. PS1, PS2, Xbox, etc.
The E74 error is all speculation. Remember the consoles of new are practically PCs. New software all the time can cause new problems in hardware or other software performance. Granted, it is up to the company to fully test it prior to its release. Microsoft at least has owned up to this problem and was fixing the error for free.
PS3 isn't clear of their problems either. Look at a current problem I have... I can't check on my trophy tag on their website for the past month. I am not the only one who has had this issue. Or how about the syncing issues people have been experiencing since MW2 launch. Or how about my GoW trophies not showing up to this date. I could go on about different unresolved issues on the PS3 side. Granted, in Sony's defense, their issues aren't as major as system failure. But any problem Microsoft has discovered gets quickly implemented. They might say they have a 3 year warranty but I have heard of a bunch of cases where Microsoft has fixed RRoD and E74 past the 3 year mark.