Still need 4 feedback from my LOWBALL SALE and come see my new sale list

Status
Not open for further replies.
[quote name='affa']we are talking about post #315, quoted below - it seems you gave this guy several winning bids, but in actuality his bids were not high enough.

for example, he only bid $6 for threads of fate. my bid of $10 should still stand.[/QUOTE]

he bid 11 after he saw u had 10 on it that's why he win it for 11
 
[quote name='Denzalo']The bids on Final Fantasy Origins. I'm sticking up for Verloren here. I feel he's in the right on this one.[/QUOTE]

what's ur problem can i help u
 
[quote name='starmask2k3']he bid 11 after he saw u had 10 on it that's why he win it for 11[/QUOTE]

Ok, now I suspect foul play, please post the post number of the bid by amc5kidz that shows $11 for Threads of Fate
 
[quote name='starmask2k3']what's ur problem can i help u[/QUOTE]


Wow, honestly, you shouldn't talk to anybody who did bid or would have bid in your sale like that. It's like you have no decency at all. If I bid on any items and you said that to me, I would have taken negative feedback and dumped all my bids. I wouldn't put up with a seller talking like that to me, especially when he was just agreeing with another member that pointed something out...
 
[quote name='Verloren']Ok, now I suspect foul play, please post the post number of the bid by amc5kidz that shows $11 for Threads of Fate[/QUOTE]
I have to say +1 to this as I don't see where he outbid.
 
[quote name='Verloren']Ok, now I suspect foul play, please post the post number of the bid by amc5kidz that shows $11 for Threads of Fate[/QUOTE]

agreed. this bid you speak of never happened.

it's quite clear from post history that i won threads of fate for $10. i don't understand what the issue is here. post 315 is amc5kidz's last post in this thread, and he clearly bid $6

EDITED TO ADD: you know, i noticed this going on during the bidding on occasion - i even posted about it earlier, where people were getting credited with bids they didn't make... and then people saw your 'bid totals' on the first page and 'outbid' bids that never happened. i assumed this was just you being a bit sloppy, but now i'm concerned that it was bid padding. please show me which post i was outbid on.
 
*Points at CAG Newbie sign* Is it possible to have a moderator of some kind check over this thread?

Right now, even if the bids do finally get fixed (lol...), I don't feel safe handing over any amount of money.
 
[quote name='affa']agreed. this bid you speak of never happened.

it's quite clear from post history that i won threads of fate for $10. i don't understand what the issue is here. post 315 is amc5kidz's last post in this thread, and he clearly bid $6

EDITED TO ADD: you know, i noticed this going on during the bidding on occasion - i even posted about it earlier, where people were getting credited with bids they didn't make... and then people saw your 'bid totals' on the first page and 'outbid' bids that never happened. i assumed this was just you being a bit sloppy, but now i'm concerned that it was bid padding. please show me which post i was outbid on.[/QUOTE]

It also seems strange that amc's bids which clearly were not high bids on some items were then listed as being the high bids and when totaled up equate to $54 which is $1 more than Karma's $53 who I noticed bid on alot of items hoping to make high bidder for the free game but now the finalized totals appear to show amc as the winner due to the dubious bids.
 
[quote name='affa']your final is incorrect - i won threads of fate with my 10 bid.

amc5kidz only bid $6 in post 315, which didn't beat the current bid.[/QUOTE]


[quote name='starmask2k3']the bids was not updated when people was bidding on the stuff[/QUOTE]


I get what he is doing now. He gave amc $11 because he bid after affa, but the bid wasn't high enough to bid affa. He assumed amc meant $11 since he was trying to bid the highest amount on that item.
 
i just had problems with the internet because it was going very slow and because of the very fast winds and because of that I can't keep up with the bids.bids where coming in very fast i'am very very sorry about that. i just wanted this to go well and i wanted to get my feedback higher because i wanted to hit 200 feedback so i am not going anywhere because i love CAG because i am a CAG for LIFE and again i am very very sorry about this
 
[quote name='momouchi']I get what he is doing now. He gave amc $11 because he bid after affa, but the bid wasn't high enough to bid affa. He assumed amc meant $11 since he was trying to bid the highest amount on that item.[/QUOTE]

when people bid on stuff i assumed they wanted to be the higher bid so i added a dollar.if my internet was not slow like it was this would be ok for some reason.it was slow at the last hour so it was very hard to keep up with bids and again i very sorry
 
[quote name='backseatdog']lol I thought this ended monday night. Kinda glad I missed it now after reading all the recent posts. Yikes![/QUOTE]

it ended 2/22 12 am
 
[quote name='rick1000']your doing great starmask dont listen to theaes assholes[/QUOTE]

it was just that hour that killed me because the internet was so so slow
 
So what's my total and what the heck is going on?

It doesn't make sense logically what you're doing. You took my bids for $10 on the Guncons which were clearly a $1 more than the previous bidders. But for the other items that I bid on (which were too low) you just increased the bids by a dollar. Of course I want the L4D2...but I don't think the way you're running this makes sense at all.
 
guys chill out, starmask2k3 did his best to keep up with everyone, this is my first lowball and even "I" know that you should look through the thread to find the highest bids posted, its really hard to constantly keep updating stuff like that. If you want something more "fair" seriously go to ebay with it. AND you can't edit your posts. You need to stop complaining I don't see any problems here.
 
[quote name='Amc5kidz']So what's my total and what the heck is going on?

It doesn't make sense logically what you're doing. You took my bids for $10 on the Guncons which were clearly a $1 more than the previous bidders. But for the other items that I bid on (which were too low) you just increased the bids by a dollar. Of course I want the L4D2...but I don't think the way you're running this makes sense at all.[/QUOTE]

my internet was slow it was hard to update the bids so when people post the bids
i am very sorry about this. people just dont know i feel i wanted this to go well and it did'nt go well because my internet was slow
 
Last edited:
[quote name='phantasyx']guys chill out, starmask2k3 did his best to keep up with everyone, this is my first lowball and even "I" know that you should look through the thread to find the highest bids posted, its really hard to constantly keep updating stuff like that. If you want something more "fair" seriously go to ebay with it. AND you can't edit your posts. You need to stop complaining I don't see any problems here.[/QUOTE]

thank you phantasyx
 
starmask - I respect however you want to run your auction. Could you please just PM people their totals (or at least me, so I don't get so confused) and what they won? Just make an executive decision and be done with it.

Thanks!
 
[quote name='starmask2k3']BIDDERS INDEX for LOWBALL SALE #3

Shipping Cost : Most Single Game/Guide, $3.00 via 1st Class or Media Mail; then $2 more per like item [add $0.80 for tracking # required ]

Everything else, ACTUAL SHIPPING COST via USPS or FedEx will be determined (based on size & weight from zip 14213


Karma Is a Bish
114.gears of war 2 Complete]Karma Is a Bish 8
111.shadow of destinyComplete]Karma Is a Bish 4
106.Littlebig Planet Pirates level kit and costume pack code Karma Is a Bish 1
94.Final Fantasy XII Collector's Edition SteelbookComplete]Karma Is a Bish13
75.battlebots-cart onlyKarma Is a Bish1
73.The Adventures of Jimmy Neutron, Boy Genius: Jet Fusion-cart onlyKarma Is a Bish 1
69.dragonball z dead zone the movieKarma Is a Bish12
70.Family Guy - The Freakin' Sweet CollectionKarma Is a Bish2
68.the ruins unratedKarma Is a Bish5
36.Innocent Life: A Futuristic Harvest MooncompleteKarma Is a Bish 6


token2k6
112.splinter cell chaos theory limited editionComplete]token2k6 1


phantasyx-pm invoice
2.Assassin's Creed 1 LE -comes with tin,slip cover,mini strategy guide,comic,bonus DVD)
(don't come with figure,game case,game) 2
23.getting-upcomple-tephantasyx 2
28.mister mosquitomissing bookletphantasyx 2
30.megaman X collectionmissing bookletphantasyx 11
40.megaman X8Complete]phantasyx 6



dabamus
3.Rainbow 6 Vegas 2 LE-comes with case box,case,bonus DVD)
(don't come with game,poker chip key chain) 1



YawnAmuroYawn
6.Resident evil 5 CE-comes with case box,messenger bag,patch,necklace)
(don't come with game,steelbook case,figure) 4
YawnAmuroYawn
10.Time Crisis 4-comes with box case,case)
(don't come with game,guncon3)(will cost extra to ship out) 3

n3wtype
7.Saints Row 2 CE-comes with tin,slip cover,poster/map,art book)
(don't come with game,case,money clip,usb) 2

youruglyclone
9.Warhawk headset bundle-comes with box case,case)
(don't come with game,headset) 1
115.time crisis sensor dongle youruglyclone 1
107.Littlebig Planet Pirates level kit and costume pack codeyouruglyclone 3
83.gta 4 skins for PS3youruglyclone 1
77.starfox adventuresyouruglyclone1


DigitalNerd
11.BAD COMPANYDigitalNerd 1
12.ROCK BAND 2DigitalNerd 1
13.the CLUBDigitalNerd 1
14.the GODFATHER 1 the Don's editionDigitalNerd 1
15.medal of honor AirborneDigitalNerd 1
79.smackdown here comes the painDigitalNerd1
80.Guitar Hero: Aerosmith game artDigitalNerd1


Byakurai
16.ROCK BAND 1 drums set(shipping is 10 for this)Byakurai 6

Amc5kidz
18.guncon3(shipping is 5 for this)Amc5kidz 10
19.guncon3(shipping is 5 for this)Amc5kidz 10
53.threads of fate - disc only in a cd caseAmc5kidz11
47.Wild ARMs-complete but missing booklet nu-GreatestAmc5kidz5
48.Final Fantasy Origins-completeAmc5kidz11


Izod517
20.Xenosaga episode 2-Complete]Izod517 7
59.Terminator Salvation-completeIzod517 4

jousley
1.Soul Calibur 4 PE-comes with tin,slip cover,comic and art book,tournament bracket)
(don't come with shirt,code,case,game 4
24.naruto ultimate ninja 3completejousley 4

Big_Baybee
21.gataway 1-Complete]Big_Baybee2
22.gataway 2completeBig_Baybee2
32.max payne 1completeBig_Baybee1
33.max payne 2completeBig_Baybee1


jousley
24.naruto ultimate ninja 3complete jousley 4


rick1000
76.Viva Piñatarick1000 2
99.batman arkham asylum booklet rick10001

Stoic Person Eater
96.Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock (game only)Stoic Person Eater 3

Nightfox31
110.devil may cry 5th anniversary collection boxONLY THE BOX NO GAMES]Nightfox31 1


chimpian
108.Littlebig Planet Pirates level kit and costume pack codechimpian 2


snuckles
95.final fantasy 8 1998 collector's cd vol.2 disc only in a cd casesnuckles 1
92.Amazon Promotional Code($5 of credit on select TV shows on Amazon Video On Demand (must be used by March 15, 2010)(will pm winner)snuckles 1
81.Soul Calibur 4 game artsnuckles1
26.armored core 3missing bookletsnuckles1

SirSavesALot
66.talladega nightsSirSavesALot6
67.the goldeen compassSirSavesALot5

DaButtonMasher
64.sealed Weeaer make me believeDaButtonMasher1
45.kingdom hearts 2Complete]DaButtonMasher9


blackdog60
93.white XBOX 360 faceplateblackdog60 1
41.devil may cry 1Complete]blackdog604
42.devil may cry 2Complete]blackdog604
43.devil may cry 3Complete]blackdog604
44.kingdom hearts 1Complete][blackdog60 7
25dragonball z budokai tenkaichi 2completeblackdog602


kaelinronkus
84.gta 4 skins for PS3kaelinronkus1


sasukekun
82.RE 5 game art the glass is cracked in half sasukekun1


buckythekat
78.need for speed underground 2buckythekat 1
39.megaman X command missionmissing bookletbuckythekat 1

allyourblood
74.Tiny Toon Adventures: Wacky Stackers-cart onlyallyourblood1


Chairman_LMAO
71.Galerians - RionChairman_LMAO1
56.jupiter-strike-disc only in a cd caseChairman_LMAO1

Placebo
61.NBA 2k7-completePlacebo1

notwen
58.NBA Street Homecourt-completenotwen3


2supekards
55.dracula:resurrection-complete2supekards2
46.dirge of cerberus final fantasy 7Complete]2supekards8

affa
54.klonoa:door to phantonmile-disc only in a cd caseaffa 11
27.clock tower 3missing bookletaffa2

Denzalo
52.Final Fantasy 9-complete Greatest hitsDenzalo 10
50.Final Fantasy chronicles-complete Greatest hits Denzalo 7

hitsmomouchi
49.Final Fantasy 8- disc only in 4 cd casehitsmomouchi3


formerroadie
38.castlevania lament of innocenceformerroadie1
34.final fantasy X-2completeformerroadie8


SuperPhillip
35.resident evil code veronica XcompleteSuperPhillip2


detectiveconan16
31.okage shadow king-missing bookletdetectiveconan16 2
29.indigo prophecymissing bookletdetectiveconan166[/QUOTE]

bids index
 
Last edited:
[quote name='Amc5kidz']You have me listed twice on that Bidders Index.[/QUOTE]

yeah i know fixed it sorry
 
[quote name='starmask2k3']i just had problems with the internet because it was going very slow and because of the very fast winds and because of that I can't keep up with the bids.bids where coming in very fast i'am very very sorry about that. i just wanted this to go well and i wanted to get my feedback higher because i wanted to hit 200 feedback so i am not going anywhere because i love CAG because i am a CAG for LIFE and again i am very very sorry about this[/QUOTE]

well, you can start by putting me as the high bidder on threads of fate for $10, which i am.

also, when someone points out the exact post where you made your mistake, you should do the research and realize 'hey, they are right', rather than brush them off and tell them the other person bid again after that, which they didn't.
 
SERIOUSLY, this is ridiculous. you repost the 'bidder's index' and you STILL have amc5kidz winning threads of fate. THIS IS INCORRECT, and i've already proved it.

please fix this immediately.

I stayed up watching this darn thing. why the heck would i think i would have to raise my own winning bid if i see someone bid less than me? if i have 10, and i see someone bid 6, why should i have to then repost a bid for 12? that's absurd.

amc5kidz has even posted he had incorrect bids. fix this.

To Amc5kidz -- please do the right thing and tell Starmask you didn't win the items you didn't win.
 
[quote name='affa']SERIOUSLY, this is ridiculous. you repost the 'bidder's index' and you STILL have amc5kidz winning threads of fate. THIS IS INCORRECT, and i've already proved it.

please fix this immediately.

I stayed up watching this darn thing. why the heck would i think i would have to raise my own winning bid if i see someone bid less than me? if i have 10, and i see someone bid 6, why should i have to then repost a bid for 12? that's absurd.

amc5kidz has even posted he had incorrect bids. fix this.

To Amc5kidz -- please do the right thing and tell Starmask you didn't win the items you didn't win.[/QUOTE]


One thing on lowball sales is you NEVER raise a bidder's bid by one dollar if they match the current bid WITHOUT that bidder's okay. From what I've seen, Amc didn't okay Starmask raising his bid by one dollar, which makes that void, and you, in fact, the winner, which should be fixed immediately....
 
[quote name='Vulgarism']One thing on lowball sales is you NEVER raise a bidder's bid by one dollar if they match the current bid WITHOUT that bidder's okay. From what I've seen, Amc didn't okay Starmask raising his bid by one dollar, which makes that void, and you, in fact, the winner, which should be fixed immediately....[/QUOTE]
I agree with this and I also think a bidder should review the thread before placing a bid to see where things are at especially when the lowball is within the final hours. And if they place a bid lower than a previous bid said bid should be invalid. Second I remember the last time you had a lowball and how things went down then. And the way things went down again doesn't seem fitting for a dv8mad lowball to me at least as I've not seen problems like these occurring with other dv8mad lowball's. Slow Internet is no excuse for bid padding which clearly was happening and pointed out but you just chose to ignore it and be rude to bidders in your own sale, you could have also mentioned your slow Internet problem last night if it was affecting your ability to run your lowball but again this didn't happen. One only needs to read through the last few pages of the thread to see where people pointed out they never bid on items or that amount and you ignored what they were pointing out.
 
by starmasks logic, if i make the high bid on an item, say, $8, and beat another bidder by 10 seconds who also bids $8, that SECOND bidder somehow wins the item for... $9. absurd. furthermore, for me to actually win that item, i (or someone else) now has to bid $10!

this forces bids up high, fast, by increasing the bid count even when it shouldn't.

the way this lowball is being run is unethical. it's bid padding, pure and simple. when notified of his errors, he isn't fixing them.

starmask, fix your mistakes. run your lowball with integrity or don't run it at all.
 
I'm not a fan of how he is running this lowball he completely ignores my bid which was in way before the lowball ended and I was never outbid. You missed my $2 bid on Galerians Rion. I won it.... Please solve this issue.
 
[quote name='GogetaSS4']I'm not a fan of how he is running this lowball he completely ignores my bid which was in way before the lowball ended and I was never outbid. You missed my $2 bid on Galerians Rion. I won it.... Please solve this issue.[/QUOTE]

Your bid was 14 minutes late... get over it. Stop reposting the same false complaint and everyone chill.
 
[quote name='affa']by starmasks logic, if i make the high bid on an item, say, $8, and beat another bidder by 10 seconds who also bids $8, that SECOND bidder somehow wins the item for... $9. absurd. furthermore, for me to actually win that item, i (or someone else) now has to bid $10!

this forces bids up high, fast, by increasing the bid count even when it shouldn't.

the way this lowball is being run is unethical. it's bid padding, pure and simple. when notified of his errors, he isn't fixing them.

starmask, fix your mistakes. run your lowball with integrity or don't run it at all.[/QUOTE]
shut up "CAG IN TRAINING
 
I just want this cleared up - I'm not sure how he wants to run this lowball but the problem is if he's not paying attention to numbers after people bid, then I should have won the Guncons for cheaper.

So either A - I didn't win Threads of Fate or Origins or B - I won it and I also won the Guncons for 8 and 7 dollars and Wild Arms for 3.
 
[quote name='rick1000']shut up "CAG IN TRAINING[/QUOTE]

i don't care if 'i'm in training', it doesn't change the fact that this lowball has issues.

post 315 had many bids in it that were not the high bid, yet it won them anyway.
 
dude he never mentioned which time zone so how was I supposed to know it was EST. This is bullshit I won't be bidding in any of his lowballs as he seems to not know what he is doing. All his post said was "ENDS at midnight to night" no specification as to which time zone!
 
[quote name='rick1000']shut up "CAG IN TRAINING[/QUOTE]


Hah... I am leaning towards that being a joke. Starmask did a terrible job on the end of this lowball sale. I know a few people complaining have held lowball sales, and they are difficult, but not on this scale. It's the bidder's responsibility to check the current bid. The last hour usually is pretty rough (not in this case, not much activity) but the seller usually steps aside and quits updating the OP in the last hour. It's too much work. Starmask really screwed some people over, to be honest. The biggest thing that strikes me as bullshit is he doesn't even have the end tallies in the OP. Instead, you have to search out post 370 to find your bids, and to make sure he didn't screw them up. I'd cut the guy a break if he didn't dig a hole so deep. I know he's had problems before, and this seemed like his last chance, and he messed up. Again.
 
[quote name='GogetaSS4']dude he never mentioned which time zone so how was I supposed to know it was EST. This is bullshit I won't be bidding in any of his lowballs as he seems to not know what he is doing. All his post said was "ENDS at midnight to night" no specification as to which time zone![/QUOTE]

Not only was he counting down the time in the thread, but he said closed. Get over it dude. It's a $2 item you lost.
 
[quote name='Vulgarism']Hah... I am leaning towards that being a joke. Starmask did a terrible job on the end of this lowball sale. I know a few people complaining have held lowball sales, and they are difficult, but not on this scale. It's the bidder's responsibility to check the current bid. The last hour usually is pretty rough (not in this case, not much activity) but the seller usually steps aside and quits updating the OP in the last hour. It's too much work. Starmask really screwed some people over, to be honest. The biggest thing that strikes me as bullshit is he doesn't even have the end tallies in the OP. Instead, you have to search out post 370 to find your bids, and to make sure he didn't screw them up. I'd cut the guy a break if he didn't dig a hole so deep. I know he's had problems before, and this seemed like his last chance, and he messed up. Again.[/QUOTE]

Agreed. I just hope the items I do get..are in good condition and aren't as messed up as this lowball. :(
 
[quote name='sagecooker']58.NBA Street Homecourt-complete4
59.Terminator Salvation-complete5[/QUOTE]

PLEASE don't add to the shitstorm. The lowball ended 16 hours ago, and clearly states this in the title.
 
[quote name='Amc5kidz']I just want this cleared up - I'm not sure how he wants to run this lowball but the problem is if he's not paying attention to numbers after people bid, then I should have won the Guncons for cheaper.

So either A - I didn't win Threads of Fate or Origins or B - I won it and I also won the Guncons for 8 and 7 dollars and Wild Arms for 3.[/QUOTE]

unfortunately, this isn't how lowballs work. you bid $10 on both guncons in post #315, which i believe to be the high bid. this means you win both for $10 each. you get items at your bid.

however, your $6 bid on Threads of Fate was not the highest, so you shouldn't win that.

likewise, you only bid $6 on 48.Final Fantasy Origins-complete, yet somehow won that for $11 even though you shouldn't have.

for some reason, everything worked correctly for some of your other bids - for example, you only bid $4 on Kingdom Hearts, but weren't magically 'upgraded' to a winning bid of $8 like you were for other items.

i'm also pretty sure Karma won Dragonball for only 11, not 12, though i'd need to triple check that. he only bid $11 in post 318 right before close, so either he won it for 11 or someone else already did, though i didn't see it and i'm pretty sure he had high bid.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
bread's done
Back
Top