[quote name='dtcarson']I wouldn't mind if the VC offered some XBLA functionality, even without online play.
I think Play doesn't deserve the not-so-good reviews it's gotten. I think most of them think of it as a fullprice game with a free remote, or that they (being reviewers and all) already have a bunch of remotes. I'll admit, that's a big caveat, an extra remote that isn't needed, but that should be taken into account with the review.
If you need/want another remote, and especially if you have people you'd like to draw into gaming, or you like 'pick up and play' games, Play's a nobrainer. If you are a totally single player, no one else even ever watches you play, and you already have all the remotes you need, then yes, Play probably loses a few points.[/quote]
It deserves those reviews, as this is a launch titles that's coming way too late to the party to serve its purpose. Luckily, remotes are still hard to find, so there's still some demand for it, but if this had come out at launch, the scores would be better.