The controller looks like fun... Don't be hatin. Yeah, and we had a huge thread on this well over a month ago. Don't mean to be mean, but like RvB, I'm defensive about the cool looking chainsaw controller.
Yeah, it would look good on a bookshelf, perhaps as a convorsation piece. But please, it doesn't look like it would actually control the game well, much less sit comfortably in your hands for more than 10 minutes.
I use an S for everything except FPSs. My hands are pretty big and I like the longer travel of the sticks on the original. I also pull the triggers with my middle fingers and use my pointers for stability. They don't really have as good of a place to rest with an S.
I can't imagine playing DOAU with those mushy face buttons, though.
RE4 is gonna be great. Fedex should have it on my doorstep tomorrow