Wow, blackout, you were there live, and you didn't feel the intensity of the crowd in the Taker match? He doesn't need to be out at all there.
Myk, your on to something (I think we had this conversation in a previous thead). But, I'm thinking about it long term here. Maybe I'm wrong here (I admit I'm not sure I believe this fully), but I think this could be what Vince and company is thinking
If you don't catch wrestling fans early, you won't have them. I talk to my friends. If you're 20 something and watching wrestling, you were watching it when you were 10 and below. I don't have a friend that started watching as a teenager, it was younger than that. Now, do some people get in later, I'm sure. But, I think the bulk is young.
You have so many of these "ass kicker" characters that don't really care about the crowd, just do what they do. Kennedy is that right now. Booker was pretty much that before becoming King. Finley is this character now. Austin was that character, so was the Rock. This isn't the full list.
Cena is really the only guy right now playing the "good guy" role. Sure, it's forced, no one is that good in real life, the character is bound to have some issues. But, Cena pulls it off to SOME extent. I'm convinced Cena has nothing to do with the core audience right now, Cena is to build the future audience (Vince owns the business right now, Cena is to bring in the future audience in 10-15 years, the same audience that wold still boo him).
I look at Hogan. If you played Hogan's 1980's character right now, it would bomb. Yet, if he shows up at an event, he tears off his shirt, does a few poses, and tons of us turn into Hogan marks.
Honestly, if you are 7-8 years old (or younger) who will you identify with (hard to put yourself there without having one in your life). You want the super hero guy that follows the rules (reasonably) and can prevail. This is what Cena is. Is it believable, not really. Do those that root for Cena really care, I don't think so.
Now, is there a way to have a best of all worlds, I think so. But, it would take some work.
I have a sketch in my mind that could save him. I think you need a heel with heat. I think Khali is perfect for this. But, he needs to have some alliances with some other guys (sort of like an old Ministry of Darkness that taker had). Let this group led by Khali (or your choice of person). Absolutely cost Cena everything. Have them cost Cena the title, have Cena's professional life fall apart because of this group. Then, have Cena "snap" and start rushing the ring destroying every match on Raw, literally grinding the show to a halt (this happened often during the attitude era), and have him systematically destroy this group until he comes up to the top. I think taking some hard hits on tv can win him fans of the older crowd, while keeping his character for the younger generation.