I'll echo the question on what you want to use them for and the weather conditions. Personally, I only really rock a knit beanie when I have to clean the snow off my car, fur-lined leather gloves when it goes under 40, and Earthkeeper Timberlands when it goes under 30 and/or wet/snowy, since I'm only outdoors for 5 minutes at the most.
If I had to be outdoors for more than 15 minutes, I would rock one of those wool hats with the ear covers, some beefier mittens, and some insulated boots.