Well I am totally disappointed in the whole TV pass thru thing. Like I said above, its a bummer you can't still just watch your cable box when the units is off. However, I think the Xbox One just doesn' like my Xfinity X1 STB. When I first hooked it all up, it kind of worked, but if I said "watch MTV" or "watch HBO" the channel never changed, even though the Xbox One said it was currently 'watching' that channel.
I turned the system off and came back an hour later. Now the TV video had NO sound and would freeze every 4 seconds. Very frustrated at this point I unplugged and hard reset everything. When I did this to the cable box, all hell with resolution and aspect ratios broke loose. Stretched screens, glitchy screens, cut-off screeens, everything! So I just said screw it, unplugged my BD player and put my cable box thru there, Xbox One on dedicated HDMI as well. Well, then when I went to the cable box input, I had a little tiny image on the center of the screen, still no sound, still freezing. This thing was like a 280p box in the center. I was freaking the f**k out! So, another hard reset to the cable box and thankfully the issue resolved itself.
At least for me, I don't think this TV stuff is ready for prime time. It could be b/c I am using the Xfinity X1 stuff which has a myriad of bugs of its own. I am using a 'satellite' STB, not the actually DVR unit, but I'm not about to switch the boxes out. I'm just going to forget about the TV connection on the Xbox One for now unless its gets improved vastly. Bummer b/c I thought it was going to be a cool feature and the best one to make use of voice commands.
Other than that, IDK, I think the PS4 is better. Over an hour to download a 6gb Forza update AND install it? I had 4 games on the PS4 updated and installed and started first five minutes of in an hour last week..The controller sucks balls, way too small, especially to hit the bumper buttons and the D-pad is so clicky clicky feeling..