[quote name='ZombieToast']I agree that Earthbound is way overhyped, but I'd say it's still worth playing. It's just not worth the price for a physical copy.[/QUOTE]
Agreed.
[quote name='Vinny']Let me put on my smug hat for a moment.
Earthbound is one of those games that wasn't awesome because of its mechanics, it was awesome because of how weird and fresh it was. It was set in a modern era (instead of some medieval/fantasy setting), with some normal kids as the main character, the most annoying arch-nemesis (

ing Pokey... the neighbor kid you've always hated), with tons of pop culture references, the best enemies (hippies), calls from your mom, and whole lot complete randomness. Plus, I loved the humor in the game, which was a nice change from all the serious JRPGs back then (besides SMRPG).
I guess you may not be able to appreciate Earthbound if you played it in the more recent years (since RPGs have come a long way since then) but I played it back in 06 and 07 and loved it for what it was.
Earthbound is pretty standard RPG if you're just looking for gameplay, but if you go into an RPG just for the gameplay, then you're playing the wrong genre.[/QUOTE]
Don't get me wrong, I'm not hating on it. I played it though about 15 years ago and enjoyed doing so. It's just nothing to get super excited about for me and DEFINITELY NOT worth 150+ for a stupid loose cart. That's horse shit IMO. I'll play in on my Xbox/PS2/Dreamcast if I really want to, and I'm a big supporter of playing games on their original systems without emulation.
Maybe I'm just sour that it's become such a fad to own it among the newb retro collector kiddies.