Who wants The Lord of the Rings Online: Steely Dawn Starter Pack?
It's a pretty fun, freemium MMO that you can actually progress pretty far without having to buy anything, I apparently had about 200 hours on it before I lost interest. I might have to go back to it and give it another try now that I have a new quest pack from my HB copy. I'd recommend purchasing the shared storage with the turbine points, that let's you trade items between characters, that way you don't have to rely on finding other people to do crafting for you.
Another thing I like about the game is it's equipping system solves the style vs. substance dilemma. You can equip armor, boots, gloves, helmet, etc. for stat gains and that can be shown as visible to others or instead you can put different items in the equivalent cosmetic slots. Love the stat gains on a helmet but think it's butt ugly? Put a sweet cavalier hat in the cosmetic head slot and it will display that instead of the ugly helmet.