Of those that haven't been pushed off...
[quote name='crushtopher']sealed copy of Diablo for PS1[/QUOTE]
I got a copy of that. I played a ton of it -- great co-op, though I mostly played solo.
[quote name='Jedi1979']not to hate on pc games but this should be limited to console games....there are so many obscure PC games out there, i could just dig out the old Ti-99 games or Commodore 64 games...[/QUOTE]
There's a good chance I have some of the same TI games in a box somewheres -- Hunt The Wumpus, Munch-Man, Parsec, etc.
[quote name='eayoti']I'm surprised no one has a copy of Sin and Punishment for N64. Damn, I've been looking for that game for some time...[/QUOTE]
Got that. Mint.
[quote name='furyk']My real answer though is a Game Boy game called Quarth which is Tetris if Tetris was a top down shooter. Well worth tracking down if you can find it.[/QUOTE]
Bought a cart-only copy at EB a few years back, only to find it didn't work no matter how much I cleaned it. I found out too late to return it, too.
[quote name='Justden']I was going to say Superman Returns for 360 (though I think others own it, I don't think anyone else would admit to it)[/QUOTE]
I got one (sent from EA).
[quote name='Dandeschain']Hmm, the oddest game I have is Silhouette Mirage for the psx. I'm sure there are plenty of Treasure nuts around here that have it though.[/QUOTE]
Got that one, and really liked it.
It's a shame the OP mentioned it had to be for purchase in a store, because I have a preview copy of Kameo for Xbox (not 360) that would probably win. I'm not sure Space Impact for N-Gage was ever officially released, either. I also think Japanese imports are kind of cheating, so I won't mentioned one of them. Instead, for my ONE choice, I'll go with...
Mary-Kate and Ashley: Get a Clue for Game Boy Color! It's even factory sealed.