[quote name='trq']I'd say that's more a sign that Mexico has a major problem. I admit I haven't fully thought this through, but my gut instinct tells me: it's their money. Why can't they use it legally, as they see fit? Are we not capitalists?[/QUOTE]
Because many of them obtained the money illegally by working illegally in the United States? If they're here legally and sending that money back, fine. But, we should keep this in mind when considering allowing more legal aliens to enter the US to work, having all that money drained from the economy is not good.[quote name='bmulligan']We don't even ask those things of people who are already citizens. Why in the world should we require them for immigrants.
I can say from personal experience that every immigrant, legal and illegal, I've ever known are more hard working, ethical people than most regular americans I know.[/QUOTE]
Thats not the issue, and you probably know it. Most of them are good, hard working people. But, you can't just let anyone in who wants to come, the effects on the economy would be disastrous. You have to take a pragmatic approach to the problem of immigration, and do what best benefits the United States as a whole.
This wouldn't be an issue if the Mexican government weren't one of the most ineffective and corrupt this side of Russia. They should be a rich country, they border the United States and have significant oil assets. Their primary economic program is to encourage emigration to the United States.
Immigration is also a safety valve for their government. Those who are unhappy with the state of affairs simply leave, instead of trying to fix their country's problems. This is not an indictment of the people leaving, but of the government that encourages this in order to keep themselves in power.
The only way to have any real progress in Mexico is to clamp down on the border. It is not in the best interests of the United States to let massive numbers of Mexicans into the country.