OK, upon botticus's suggestion, I am making a thread for GameCrazy trade-in prices in this forum (where there are already FYE, Best Buy, and an old EB price thread).
I have pulled some of these out of the OLD Gamecrazy deal thread. Since that one disappears frequently (before mysteriously being resurrected ) I figure we need a more stable place for trade values. The prices will live on here. Please post as they come in - make it clear if it is value with or without MVP card and I will update the OP. Also please note that it is apparently policy at GC to drop trade-in prices as more copies of a game come in - so you may see lower prices at particular stores.
Edit 5/25: I've decided just to list MVP prices. Subtract 10% to get an estimate of trade-in without MVP, though that won't be exact. For example, DQ VIII without MVP is $16.36. For MVP pricing add 10% ($1.64) for an MVP price of $18 (but you don't get exactly $16.36 by subtracting 10% from the $18 MVP price).
Edit 5/26: Added the games from the flyer JebusMcLucifer posted. The prices on those are dated "5/25" since that's when he posted the current in-store flier.
Edit 6/7 - Please check the CAGwiki:
http://wiki.cheapassgamer.com/index.php/Game_Crazy_trade_in_values
for the latest trade-in prices!
Army Men RTS: $5.xx (May)
Geist: $18 (4/10)
Harvest Moon Magical Melody: $16 (5/25)
Odama: $22 (5/25)
Over the Hedge: $18 (5/25)
X-Men 3: $18 (5/25)
Ace Combat Zero: $18 (5/25)
Atelier Iris 2: $25 (5/25)
Backyard Wrestling 2: $3 (4/10)
Cold Winter: $6.05 (5/26)
Da Vinci Code: $18 (5/25)
Dragonquest VIII: $11 (5/28)
Eye Toy Groove: $3.30 (6/1)
Full Spectrum War. 10 Hammers: $20 (5/25)
Gallop Racer 2006: $18 (5/25)
Ghost Recon Adv. Warfighter: $25 (5/25)
Godfather: $18 (5/25)
Karaoke Rev Country: $16 (5/25)
Jak X: $7.70 (5/17)
Kingdom Hearts II: $28 (5/25)
Marc Ecko's Getting Up (regular): $18 (5/29) ($15 on 6/1?)
Metal Saga: $22 (5/25)
Midway Arcade Treasures 2: $2.75 (5/23)
MLB 2K6: $16 (5/25)
Monster Rancher Evo: $18 (5/25)
Nano Breaker: $6.60 (5/26)
Outlaw Golf 2: $5.50 (5/29)
Rise of the Kasai: $10.45 (6/1)
Samurai Western: $6.60 (5/17)
Socom 3: $20 (5/26)
Soul Calibur 3: $25 (4/22)
Suikoden V: $18 (5/25)
Tomb Raider Legend: $25 (5/25)
Tourist Trophy: $18 (5/25)
Winback 2 - Project Poseidon: $18 (5/25)
Commandos Strike Force: $18 (5/25)
Dreamfall: $18 (5/25)
Ice Age 2: $16 (5/25)
MVP 06 NCAA: $7.70 (5/17)
Outrun 2006: $13 (5/25)
Painkiller Hell Wars: $13 (5/25)
Rainbow Six Critical Hour: $13.75 (5/17)
Toca Race Driver 3: $16 (5/25)
Winback 2 - Project Poseidon: $18 (5/25)
X-Men 3: $18 (5/25)
Battlefield 2: $33 (5/25)
Blazing Angels: $30 (5/25)
DOA Arcade Stick: $15.68 (4/22)
Dynasty Warriors 5: $18 (5/25)
Elder Scrolls Oblivion: $33 (5/25)
Far Cry Instincts: $16.50 (5/16)
FIFA 2006: $30 (5/25)
Fight Night Round 3: $33 (4/12)
Final Fantasy XI: $25 (5/25)
Kameo: $18 (4/12)
NBA 2K6: $15 (5/17)
Rumble Roses XX: $33 (4/22)
The Outfit : $30 (4/22)
Tiger Woods 06: $25 (4/22)
Tomb Raider Legend: $33 (5/25)
Top Spin 2: $18 (5/25)
Animal Crossing: $14 (4/23)
Brain Age: $7.70 (5/17)
Guilty Gear: $13 (5/25)
Metroid Prime Hunters: $14 (5/25)
New Super Mario Bros.: $14 (5/25)
Tetris: $13 (5/25)
True Swing Golf: $11.xx (May)
Yoshi Touch and Go: $13.20 (5/16)
Zoo Keeper: $7.15 (5/29)
Astonishia Story: $18 (5/25)
Bust-A-Move Deluze: $18 (5/25)
Guilty Gear Judgement: $16 (5/25)
Infected: $13.75 (5/22)
Me & My Katamari: $18 (5/25)
Metal Gear Acid 2: $16 (5/25)
Outrun 2006: $14 (5/25)
Socom: $13.75 (4/22)
World Rally Championship: $16 (5/25)
Worms: $16 (5/25)
Dynasty Warriors Advance: $6.60 (6/1)
Winnie the Pooh: $6.60 (5/29)
Please submit any trades you've done at GC within the last month or so.
I have pulled some of these out of the OLD Gamecrazy deal thread. Since that one disappears frequently (before mysteriously being resurrected ) I figure we need a more stable place for trade values. The prices will live on here. Please post as they come in - make it clear if it is value with or without MVP card and I will update the OP. Also please note that it is apparently policy at GC to drop trade-in prices as more copies of a game come in - so you may see lower prices at particular stores.
Edit 5/25: I've decided just to list MVP prices. Subtract 10% to get an estimate of trade-in without MVP, though that won't be exact. For example, DQ VIII without MVP is $16.36. For MVP pricing add 10% ($1.64) for an MVP price of $18 (but you don't get exactly $16.36 by subtracting 10% from the $18 MVP price).
Edit 5/26: Added the games from the flyer JebusMcLucifer posted. The prices on those are dated "5/25" since that's when he posted the current in-store flier.
Edit 6/7 - Please check the CAGwiki:
http://wiki.cheapassgamer.com/index.php/Game_Crazy_trade_in_values
for the latest trade-in prices!
Army Men RTS: $5.xx (May)
Geist: $18 (4/10)
Harvest Moon Magical Melody: $16 (5/25)
Odama: $22 (5/25)
Over the Hedge: $18 (5/25)
X-Men 3: $18 (5/25)
Ace Combat Zero: $18 (5/25)
Atelier Iris 2: $25 (5/25)
Backyard Wrestling 2: $3 (4/10)
Cold Winter: $6.05 (5/26)
Da Vinci Code: $18 (5/25)
Dragonquest VIII: $11 (5/28)
Eye Toy Groove: $3.30 (6/1)
Full Spectrum War. 10 Hammers: $20 (5/25)
Gallop Racer 2006: $18 (5/25)
Ghost Recon Adv. Warfighter: $25 (5/25)
Godfather: $18 (5/25)
Karaoke Rev Country: $16 (5/25)
Jak X: $7.70 (5/17)
Kingdom Hearts II: $28 (5/25)
Marc Ecko's Getting Up (regular): $18 (5/29) ($15 on 6/1?)
Metal Saga: $22 (5/25)
Midway Arcade Treasures 2: $2.75 (5/23)
MLB 2K6: $16 (5/25)
Monster Rancher Evo: $18 (5/25)
Nano Breaker: $6.60 (5/26)
Outlaw Golf 2: $5.50 (5/29)
Rise of the Kasai: $10.45 (6/1)
Samurai Western: $6.60 (5/17)
Socom 3: $20 (5/26)
Soul Calibur 3: $25 (4/22)
Suikoden V: $18 (5/25)
Tomb Raider Legend: $25 (5/25)
Tourist Trophy: $18 (5/25)
Winback 2 - Project Poseidon: $18 (5/25)
Commandos Strike Force: $18 (5/25)
Dreamfall: $18 (5/25)
Ice Age 2: $16 (5/25)
MVP 06 NCAA: $7.70 (5/17)
Outrun 2006: $13 (5/25)
Painkiller Hell Wars: $13 (5/25)
Rainbow Six Critical Hour: $13.75 (5/17)
Toca Race Driver 3: $16 (5/25)
Winback 2 - Project Poseidon: $18 (5/25)
X-Men 3: $18 (5/25)
Battlefield 2: $33 (5/25)
Blazing Angels: $30 (5/25)
DOA Arcade Stick: $15.68 (4/22)
Dynasty Warriors 5: $18 (5/25)
Elder Scrolls Oblivion: $33 (5/25)
Far Cry Instincts: $16.50 (5/16)
FIFA 2006: $30 (5/25)
Fight Night Round 3: $33 (4/12)
Final Fantasy XI: $25 (5/25)
Kameo: $18 (4/12)
NBA 2K6: $15 (5/17)
Rumble Roses XX: $33 (4/22)
The Outfit : $30 (4/22)
Tiger Woods 06: $25 (4/22)
Tomb Raider Legend: $33 (5/25)
Top Spin 2: $18 (5/25)
Animal Crossing: $14 (4/23)
Brain Age: $7.70 (5/17)
Guilty Gear: $13 (5/25)
Metroid Prime Hunters: $14 (5/25)
New Super Mario Bros.: $14 (5/25)
Tetris: $13 (5/25)
True Swing Golf: $11.xx (May)
Yoshi Touch and Go: $13.20 (5/16)
Zoo Keeper: $7.15 (5/29)
Astonishia Story: $18 (5/25)
Bust-A-Move Deluze: $18 (5/25)
Guilty Gear Judgement: $16 (5/25)
Infected: $13.75 (5/22)
Me & My Katamari: $18 (5/25)
Metal Gear Acid 2: $16 (5/25)
Outrun 2006: $14 (5/25)
Socom: $13.75 (4/22)
World Rally Championship: $16 (5/25)
Worms: $16 (5/25)
Dynasty Warriors Advance: $6.60 (6/1)
Winnie the Pooh: $6.60 (5/29)
Please submit any trades you've done at GC within the last month or so.