I just remember Enter Electro being really buggy. There was one level you had to swing to the top of something and I kept getting knocked down or glitched out...I did play through it though. What If? mode has me intrigued though I'll admit.Yeah, Enter Electro's What If? mode was great. Not as funny as SM1, but still pretty great. It had a nice selection of Easter Eggs involving the X-Men, too. I don't think it was as bad as you're making it out to be! I mean, you can fight clay Samurai! THAT IS SO COOL!
Pretty sure it failed to live up to the classic for everyone. I liked the costumes and a couple of the moments, but it just wasn't good enough. Ultimate Spider-Man was pretty perfect. Best Spider-man game ever besides Spider-Man 1.
I'm a little behind with my Spidey games though too. I played all the last gen ones. I played Shattered Dimensions, and Edge Of Time, but never finished Spider-Man 3 or start Web of Shadows or The Amazing Spider-Man. I might just get Amazing for Vita when that comes out even though I own it already. I played the 3DS amazing which was average. The GBA and DS ones had some great games. Ultimate being one of them as well. I also need to go back to that 2D spider-man game for PSP I was almost done with it and my save overwrote itself....someday I'll go back. It was also a buggy mess but sort of fun.