It's a dead horse with LRGs mission statement etched in stone, but I'm still perplexed why anyone actually cares if they went back on that and offered reprints. I don't understand why people, who claim they aren't in it for money or reselling, are SO incredibly scared to death that they won't be able to exclusively have something that someone else can't.
You've written a lot, and in the end, it come s down to this one statement^
If you have to ask, then there is nothing here that will change your mind, or explain it away. If LRG "reprinted" a title they said they wouldn't, their "word" means nothing, and as a business, that's death.
Why say a game will be 24.99 on Friday, and then once you buy, it's 30.99, or 39.99? How would that go over? Just because you have no moral issue with them going back on their word, says exactly who and what you are, and that's fine. If you want to say one thing, and do another, it's your life, and if you gain success with that, great. If not, that's also fine.
I personally don't deal with anyone who I can't trust, and that applies to friends, family, and businesses. It's just who I am, and how I deal in life. I personally don't really care if games are reprinted, as Soldner saw one shortly after LRG released it, and I was happy to see others who missed out, get a copy.
LRG is about more than the end user(of course we are the main piece to the puzzle), but there is more at stake than if you or me get a game cheap. If they go back on their mission statement, how do you think that would affect future deals with publishers? If I knew a company lied, are where not honest, I wouldn't be dealing with them, and I would assume, they would loose any future business from most places, as now they would be "untrustworthy" and their business is over, just as fast as it started.
Great, you now can get B&C cheap, and they now go out of business, as those developers now see them as crooks and liars, and now their business is over, house payments gone, kids college fund is toast, and a business two guys built from the ground up is ash, but that's great, as you got the game you wanted right? So all is good.