[quote name='BSETI50']Yea that's the deal with a third rounder goin to arzona, we just wanted thougghts on whether a third rounder was too high[/QUOTE]
I'm not sure if it's breaks-the-trade high, but I think the pick is unnecessary. Fact is, Wells is a completely redundant player in the Arizona offense given his plethora of backs (setting aside AP, he still has Williams, Sproles, and Stephens-Howling). So he's getting rid of essentially a spare part on his team and meanwhile getting what could be a high upside player back.
Looking at McCarthy's skills, he's got good speed, high tackle, good play recognition. He's already a pretty useful player even if he doesn't progress. (In fact, I kind of want him now, lol).
I'd say it's a fair deal straight up, but if you need to include a pick I'd say it should be lower.