[quote name='reddjoey']Official reviews?? Like only CheapyD, Wombat, or Shipwreck? I think OXM is a reputable source (especially since they named Mass Effect their GOTY in 2007). I don't think it "spoiled" the game for anyone by mentioning one reviews brief synopsis and score. If you want to walk in with no knowledge of the game till you stick it in the drive, why would you be in this thread before then? Since you complained, I happily removed it. I just don't think we see eye to eye[/QUOTE]
I think my post was misinterpreted. I definitely did not point that last part at one specific person, and most certainly did not intend for there to be any underlying hostility (hence the "

")
I'm not against anyone posting reviews in here - from OXM, IGN, GameSpot, etc. - because all those are major outlets and various people like seeing/hearing what they have to say. I was just saying that those kinds of things should be in spoiler tags because not every source knows what the meaning of "spoiler" is (I'd rather just use the blanket generalization that any review may have a spoiler in it - to be safe). The only reason I quoted anyone within the past two days talking/asking about the OXM article was just to point them at previous posts that included the scan so they could see it for themselves.
My use of the phrase
official reviews was meant to discourage any posts of impressions or hands-on articles that sites have been posting since the embargo was lifted in mid-December, not to call you or anyone else out for OXM discussions. I know for a fact that many impressions (especially the ones of the first 90 minutes of the game) are just full of information that's best left un-spoiled. Whenever these sites start posting reviews of the entire game, along with w/e score or system they use,
that's when it's cool to post here in spoiler tags. I just don't want the
impressions and
hands-on information here at all, unless it comes from a BioWare dev.
I think I''ve made it excruciatingly obvious (via making/organizing the thread, updating the thread with almost every big news announcement/article that exists, etc.) that I am interested in knowing all I can about ME2, but I'm keeping it spoiler-free for myself and others.
Sorry if any bad wording on my part lead to the impression that I was calling you or any others out.