[quote name='A Happy Panda']Would you guys recommend picking up a classic controller, or just getting some Wavebirds? I never had a GC, so I don't have any controllers. I was just wondering if it felt weird playing Genesis or SNES games on the GC controllers?[/quote]
Taking the opinion of the above poster, eh, it's a matter of personal preference I think. Many people can't stand the tiny D pad on the Wavebird, and the button layout bugs some, others, they don't care.
I've got $20 in my wallet now, and a Wavebird at home that plays everything. That $20 stays in my wallet till I see something that tells me otherwise in picking up a Classic controller.
Obviously some games are not all unchanged ports, as Super Castlevania saw the analog stick on my Wavebird and used it like an 8 way Dpad. It was pretty nice to use inplace of the teensy D-pad on there. Button layout leaves something to be desired, but then again, I think I remember SCastlevania having button remapping, and I just didn't check it last night... So, if I can remap my whip to A and jumping to B, we got no problems jack.
The flipside of the Classic controller (past the GC thing) is that some people don't like the cable coming out the bottom or that the controller is tethered to a loose Wiimote you have to keep track of while playing.
Frankly, I'd take the gameplay either way, since I've been playing most of these games on emulators with a keyboard for years anyway, a different controller scheme isn't a deal killer here.