Second sale, the guy might have been into my GF, especially after the first thing she got excited over was a Star Trek TNG How to Host a Mystery game. He also had a boxed PS1 mouse.
Also told us he had a Virtual Boy for sale, and he wanted $50 for it, but would go less. I offered $40 for everything, and he said ok. Actually, he said just for me, but it was pretty obvious, since if I bought it, he couldn't exactly offer it to anyone else.
I'm sure the GF would not be happy if I didn't say I wasn't interested in it at all, but she made me take a look. Then she spotted the game on the top left. Yep, that's right. Super rare Atlus game.