Well, I played a few games yesterday and I'm a bit mixed. I really want to like it since it's Next-Gen baseball.
Pro's
- Swing stick seems ok (I usually prefer button, but I'm getting used to it, feels pretty smooth actually)
- Baserunning seems easy enough
- I could SAC bunt (stated above that others couldn't)
- Ambience is nice with stadiums flyby's, replays, etc
Cons
- FIELDING. HORRIBLE. The camera is a mess, I tried turning off "Keep fielder in center (or whatever it's called)" and that seems a little better. Hopefully the retail game gives us multiple camera angles
- The blue fielding circle blends in too much. Outfielders seem to lunge at most balls. I had Chavez completely drop a routine fly ball.
- Wall Climbs seems TOO easy this year.
- Throwing animations are weird. Throws on the run almost every play on a grounder
- I noticed a player completely run out of the basebath to avoid a tag...went from dirt to the inner grass...they called the runner SAFE (which he should be out for going completely out of the basebath).
Side note, not sure how I feel about the scorecard interaction for swapping players. I liked MVP's way of doing it....just something to get used too.
There are more of both, but I'm still comparing to MVP 05, which is still superior IMO. Graphics don't really mean nothing to me if the gamplay is lacking.
I'll still pick up probably....but I was a bit mixed about this. I'm sure once I get all the controls down, it will be better.