[quote name='botticus']Bumping to confirm $9.99 for new copies. Copy at my store wasn't as bad as I had recalled, so I got mine.[/quote]
I found the same this past weekend. I was actually going to GS to find a used copy for $8.99. What a good surprise to find it GS-new for $9.99.
My receipt didn't have the "PO" or any mention of it being new. It reads:
Shin Megami Tense 9.99
281569 028/000
Also, I took the $9.99-labelled, no-disc, heavily-fingerprinted, greasy case + manual to the front so I could check the disc condition. She took the case from me and handed me another. The 2nd game case had a sticker on it that said $39.99. The 2nd case really looked new as did the manual. I checked the disc and it was perfect. She asked me if everything was OK and I nodded. Then, she smiled and said, "Not every Gamestop treats their games like crap."