I can't disagree with your points - they're totally valid; other than some basic modernizations to the MP, and a much better campaign, It is more or less Starcraft.
I think thats what they were going for, though.. Its what people expected. It's hard for me to decide if 'its just like Starcraft' should be held against them, or if they should get some points for recognizing that Starcraft was exactly what a huge number of their customers wanted.
I look at Starcraft 2 - which took the lessons from its first game, improved some things (peon management, queuing, etc), and then I look at Supreme Commander 2 - which took everything the player base loved, lit it on fire and peed on the ashes. I think Blizzard deliberated pretty hard about the direction of the game.. I mean, didn't they scrap near-final versions of the game two or three times in the development process? What they came up with is solid, but no also not ground breaking at all.
[quote name='RichMeisterMan']Wow, hopefully the reviewers don't choke on the balls. I don't want to sound like a hater, but we all paid 60 bucks for a game that is damn near the same as its predecessor. The reviews seem to take note of this, but still give it a perfect score? Had this been another game that did the same thing it would be slammed.
"This isn't just a fresh coat of paint on StarCraft, it is StarCraft, right down to its pixelated bones."
"Not a lot of chances were taken, but Blizzard knows what works, and it shows."
The game is great and deserves the stellar sales and accolades, but at the same time it's so great it doesn't need these reviewers to fellate it. If you have the first Starcraft I wouldn't go breaking the bank to buy this one.
I'm really not trying to rub anyone the wrong way and I really hope to see the games multiplayer expand with the next chapters of the game.
On another note, some of the reviewers act like there were no good RTS games between the Starcraft titles and that's a load of horse shit. Hello?! Company of Heroes much?
I'm interested in doing some MP, more or less to learn some shit. So if there's anyone here that kicks ass and would like to take me to school or anyone who also
sucks ass feel free to add me. I know you can link up with facebooks. And I think emails?
[email protected][/QUOTE]