62 games later and 36 wins I can say this has been worth my time.
But maybe only because the fact SF:AC is dead on XBox Live, so this is pretty much the only real choice for anyone to get into 2d fighting online without having to fight too many leet players.
The D-Pad is pretty bad, but I played SFA3 on a PS1 controller for a good year and got use to that shitty D-Pad (Opinions, the PS2 D-Pad blows ass for 2d fighting games but was still better then the XBox d-pad,and in this case the 360 d-pad, but still) and was able to pull off moves pretty easily. So I'm sure with alot of practice anyone can become good with the D-Pad. It's justa learning curve.
I mainly use Zangief. I can honestly say that the analog is pretty well done for 360 (as in people who want to pull off 360's) players so I had fun with beef. I was able to pull off SPD's 75% of the time and I'm sure that will be higher down the road.
The main concern I'm sure on everybodys mind is the LAG. There is little to no lag in 95% of my matchs. I hosted about 70% of the time and I wouldn't get lag. When I went to look for another match I would only get lag if I decided to play against someone with less then a green bar. There is little to no lag in this game compared to SF:AC was over Live. Some very good news indeed. You can debate this, but as long as you follow the green bar rule there is no lag. Either that your connection to Live blows ass.
Another concern there seems to be is E.Honda. Yeah, he's cheap when lag comes to play, and sometimes theres little way around him. He was one of the best players to abuse with and that isn't going to change.
One other little gripe (can be major depending on youre view) is your NOT able to play RANKED Quarter Mode matchs. This kinda sucks.
Achievements? They are pretty easy to get with the exception of winning single player without losing a road/match .Even at 0 star difficulty the computer can still be tricky.
Lastly, the other issue is 800 points that everyone (myself included at one time) has groaned about. Let me repeat what I first said: This is the only MAJORLY ACTIVE 2d fighting game out there. You may be able to still get KOF or SF:AC games over XBox Live, but finding new people and moderate skill is RARE. Newbie or Pro you will your home here by fighting people of various skill, and I'm sure this will remain the same for the 360's life span till they decide to release more 2d fighters on Live. This game is easily worth 800 points for the lag free gameplay (most of the time) and enviroment alone. The only thing that can be worked on imho is a adaptor so we can use better controlers, or for them to release another SF:AC arcade stick.
Thats my two cents, any questions feel free to ask.