[UPDATE] Super Mario All-Stars: Limited Edition (Wii) Reprint - $29.99 [3/13/11]

iNCREDiPiNOY

CAGiversary!
Feedback
216 (100%)
Super Mario All-Stars: Limited Edition (Wii) Reprint

  • 4 Classic Mario Games
  • Super Mario History soundtrack CD
  • Super Mario History booklet featuring original art and interviews

Retailers


Amazon - Available in stock
Best Buy - Available in stock
Gamestop (gamestop.com/wii/games/super-mario-all-stars-limited-edition/87690) - Available in stock
Toys R' Us - Available in stock
 
Last edited by a moderator:
[quote name='confoosious']You're done cause you can't answer my question? Gotcha.[/QUOTE]

Yup, you're the man. Pat yourself on the back and tell yourself you just won a discussion that can't be won because no one is right or wrong.
 
[quote name='MaelstromB']Yup, you're the man. Pat yourself on the back and tell yourself you just won a discussion that can't be won because no one is right or wrong.[/QUOTE]

hahah still avoiding the question. :lol: :bouncy:

It's a very simple one: do you own SMAS?
 
[quote name='confoosious']hahah still avoiding the question. :lol: :bouncy:

It's a very simple one: do you own SMAS?[/QUOTE]

OMG man. Please, let it go already.

As I stated earlier, no. Is your next question going to ask to see my bank statement to make sure? And, just for the record, all I originally did was state my opinion about the game in a thread about the game. It holds no weight that this is a thread about a reprint. I would have said the same thing in the original thread, but sorry, never got around to it then.

Fact is, this is a forum, and in forums ppl state their opinions. You then took it personally and dragged it into an ongoing argument. Nuff said.
 
YES! Finally gonna get this game~

I preordered the game from TRU. Course, I did that at full price. But I really don't care at this point. I was expecting to drop 50dollars+. But if you folks see any deals, I'd appreciate it if you mention it soon.

Thanks.
 
[quote name='RabbitSuit']YES! Finally gonna get this game~

I preordered the game from TRU. Course, I did that at full price. But I really don't care at this point. I was expecting to drop 50dollars+. But if you folks see any deals, I'd appreciate it if you mention it soon.

Thanks.[/QUOTE]

Doubt there will be any deals but I can't imagine TRU and GS get a shipment of reprints and Amazon doesn't. I was gonna order on TRU too but saw the shipping and stopped. I'm holding out for an Amazon allocation. At least you'll save on shipping and maybe tax.

I'm sure someone will post here as soon as it's available.
 
Since when do people judge products based on what's not in them?

For $30, I was super-excited to get the SNES SMAS collection. I never had All-Stars on SNES, so this was the first time I got to play those games with that art style. Also, the only time I've played the Lost Levels was on Super Mario Bros. Deluxe on GBC, and that was a greatly altered version.

I thought the artbook was cool. Nothing serious, but cool to check out. And I loved the mini-soundtrack, especially the sound effects. The pipe noise is now my text message alert.

If you don't like it, don't buy it. But don't get upset because it doesn't contain every game that has the word "Mario" in the name. I like it. I was perfectly willing to pay $29.99 for an Amazon preorder.
 
[quote name='adamical']If you don't like it, don't buy it. But don't get upset because it doesn't contain every game that has the word "Mario" in the name.[/QUOTE]
This is the exact reason people go nuts over it and the Dreamcast Collection - they hyped themselves up, getting their expectations way too high and threw a fit when they saw neither collection had the games they expected them to have.
 
I have a sealed copy I ordered from Amazon back in October 2010. I bought it to play (me and kids), but grew concerned after reading reviews about laggy controls and such. This is why I never opened it. For those that have played it, is this a valid concern? I still have a SNES console, so I was just going to get the cart and sell this copy (if not too late!).
 
[quote name='Tsukento']This is the exact reason people go nuts over it and the Dreamcast Collection - they hyped themselves up, getting their expectations way too high and threw a fit when they saw neither collection had the games they expected them to have.[/QUOTE]

The difference is that here, Nintendo has no history of giving a ton of content for the money and is throwing in a pretty box, a booklet and a CD for the $30. Sega on the other hand has consistently given massive collections of games for the same $30 they are now charging for four ports of Dreamcast games that don't even fit well together and in the case of Crazy Taxi, are missing the music which so many of us loved in the original. So, I don't think this comparison of the relative outrage is apt at all.
 
[quote name='Blumpkin']This has got to be the most highly overrated game of the last year. It's a SNES cartridge put onto a disc.[/QUOTE]

Agreed. That said, it was nice to play them again. My SNES bit the dust a while back so it had been a long time since I played these.

The Wii controls seemed to be a bit more loose though. It was a little harder to control then before (i.e. Mario seemed to slip off the ledges a bit too easy with the Wiimote). Not complaining though -- love these games.

I do wish Ninty had added SMW and Y'sI but may be for the 30th anniversary?
 
[quote name='bojay1997']The difference is that here, Nintendo has no history of giving a ton of content for the money and is throwing in a pretty box, a booklet and a CD for the $30. Sega on the other hand has consistently given massive collections of games for the same $30 they are now charging for four ports of Dreamcast games that don't even fit well together and in the case of Crazy Taxi, are missing the music which so many of us loved in the original. So, I don't think this comparison of the relative outrage is apt at all.[/QUOTE]

Agreed 100%. At least with the SMAS collection, you get some decent games. The Sega collection is just 4 crappy substandard titles thrown together, with nothing special or desirable about them. A total waste of money and a ripoff.
 
[quote name='bojay1997']The difference is that here, Nintendo has no history of giving a ton of content for the money and is throwing in a pretty box, a booklet and a CD for the $30. Sega on the other hand has consistently given massive collections of games for the same $30 they are now charging for four ports of Dreamcast games that don't even fit well together and in the case of Crazy Taxi, are missing the music which so many of us loved in the original. So, I don't think this comparison of the relative outrage is apt at all.[/QUOTE]
Comparing Genesis games to Dreamcast games isn't a very good comparison, either, considering how many games can be pushed into a disc and there not being any further pushes of the games digitally on home consoles.

Just because you got several Genesis games thrown together in previous sets doesn't mean you should expect there to automatically be the same amount or even more than 5 on a disc.

As I said, both sets were given negative looks because people got their expectations too high, assuming they'd be getting the best games ever just because they believed it to be so based off the names.
 
[quote name='Blumpkin']This has got to be the most highly overrated game of the last year. It's a SNES cartridge put onto a disc.[/QUOTE]

Is that suppose to mean it's bad? Some of the best games ever released were snes games. Do I hear Earthbound?
 
[quote name='confoosious']Doubt there will be any deals but I can't imagine TRU and GS get a shipment of reprints and Amazon doesn't. I was gonna order on TRU too but saw the shipping and stopped. I'm holding out for an Amazon allocation. At least you'll save on shipping and maybe tax.

I'm sure someone will post here as soon as it's available.[/QUOTE]


I actually went in and preordered in store, not online. The manager there didn't know about the reprint though, and actually told me that they wouldn't be getting it again :p. But I referred him to the website and he had a two people search for their preorder cards in back.

Turns out neither of them were able to find the cards, but I was still able preorder it from there.

I'll definitely keep an eye out on Amazon though, thanks.
 
[quote name='Blumpkin']This has got to be the most highly overrated game of the last year. It's a SNES cartridge put onto a disc.[/QUOTE]

I agree to the sense where people went a little crazy paying outrageous prices in the secondary market but if people are dumb enough to pay then so be it.

In all actuality, this is Mario. Even if it is just rehash it is great for any collector which is the reason why I have 2 copies. I remember when I was kid and my parents would take me to Chuck E. Cheese and I would need a stool to try and play Mario Bros, Donkey Kong, Excite Bike, Duck Hunt, & Super Mario Bros. You just really can't hate on Mario, unless you weren't old enough to go through that era.
 
thread.jpg
 
Cool, hopefully the people that actually wanted to play it will get a chance on grabbing a copy. Damn hoarders always ruin things, but it is what it is.

I had my copy since December and I had a good bit of fun with it, and I still have a SNES with the original copy. But, the fact I can play it with a wireless controller with my fiancée is good enough for me.

And as bad as this sounds, LOL at all those who bought 3+ copies hoping for a reinvestment. You can't build a 401(k) off of damn video games, c'mon now! :D
 
[quote name='M-PG71C']
And as bad as this sounds, LOL at all those who bought 3+ copies hoping for a reinvestment. You can't build a 401(k) off of damn video games, c'mon now! :D[/QUOTE]

My PayPal account says differently.

The game is worth $30, just to be able to use the Wiimote. Glad more CAGs will get hold of the game.
 
phooey I still have my original box here I never opened lol guess I will hold on to it and buy this 2nd run to play.
 
If they do reprint this it really should be just the game disc. Reprinting a "Limited Edition" doesn't make any sense.
 
[quote name='tyrok3k']If they do reprint this it really should be just the game disc. Reprinting a "Limited Edition" doesn't make any sense.[/QUOTE]

It's called bidness, kid.
 
why are people arguing about reprints?
why are people arguing about the past?
why are people still arguing about the rarity?

and why are people still arguing about a kids game? i havent heard a single comment about this game.
 
[quote name='david12795']why are people arguing about reprints?
why are people arguing about the past?
why are people still arguing about the rarity?

and why are people still arguing about a kids game? i havent heard a single comment about this game.[/QUOTE]


This reprint gives everyone that couldn't get it the first time a second chance. People need to let go. It's a game. Back in the day, games were for having fun, but now people trying to flip it to make money.

FYI- I got 2 when released. One for me and the other a gift:)
 
[quote name='ackbar7']I am not sure why anyone thinks Nintendo has any interest in keeping the original as a valuable resale item.[/QUOTE]

Because then the next time they say something is "limited" people will again grab up all of the supply quickly at full price. If they go back on that, they risk people waiting for a price drop.

Best solution would be releasing game only for $20. Nintendo would probably make more money that way anyway.
 
[quote name='david12795']why are people arguing about reprints?
why are people arguing about the past?
why are people still arguing about the rarity?

and why are people still arguing about a kids game? i havent heard a single comment about this game.[/QUOTE]

Why is nobody complaining about the fact that Nintendo continually releases essentially the same game over, and over, and over again with the occasional update for the new system.

Mario Party, Super Smash Bros., Pokemon, Mario Kart, ect...

After all, this is simply a reprint of games that have already been reprinted/repackaged time and time again since the mid 80's. Heaven forbid they actually come up with a new franchise not related to Pokemon, Mario or dug up from the NES days.
 
[quote name='aTaRiFrEaK223']The only reason people are bitching about this reprint is because they bought 20 copies and now can't sell them for ridiculous prices.[/QUOTE]

QFT

Also people are getting upset that the game probably wont be "rare" any more, since I never considered it just hard to find.
 
[quote name='sassylaurie']After all, this is simply a reprint of games that have already been reprinted/repackaged time and time again since the mid 80's. Heaven forbid they actually come up with a new franchise not related to Pokemon, Mario or dug up from the NES days.[/QUOTE]

Wii Sports/Resort/Play/Music? Brain Age? Steel Diver? Rhythm Heaven? Nintendogs?

:roll:
 
[quote name='The Punisher']Good article. I cant believe people are willing to pay that much money.
Games of today will probably dont sell like that since Technology is getting better. Well, it depends on supply and demand.

I do have to admit, I wish I had the old NES robot.:cry:[/QUOTE]


Games can still become that rare with limited production runs, initial release errors, developer/manufacturer bankruptcy, or even with enough time. Yeah, most games won't sell like that now, especially with people cracking, emulating, and torrenting games. But it could still happen. And people can easily turn a game into net profit if they're smart about it. It's just like collecting baseball cards.

[quote name='bojay1997']Completely irrelevant article. Even if you owned all of them, you wouldn't be rich and you certainly couldn't retire on the proceeds from the sale.[/QUOTE]


The sole purpose of posting that article was to counterpoint the idea that reselling video games cannot be profitable. Again, it's just like collecting baseball cards. If anyone happens to feel that I'm wrong, and they have either a mint copy of Suikoden II, a T206 Honus Wagner or a 1952 Mickey Mantle rookie card, I'll buy it from you for $5.

Technically, you can retire at any given time. Given that Stadium Events sold for ~$41,000, the average annual income here in the United States, one could retire for a year with that given sale, then come out of retirement if they so chose. And furthermore, he was initially wrong in his assessment that you can "build" a 401(k) off from the aforementioned reselling of video games; all a 401(k) is is earned money withheld by an employer and not subjected to income tax until after retirement. Where do you propose the employer is in a "buy this exceedingly rare game, hold onto it, and resell it for a sizable profit later" scenario? One could also invest that money in stocks, like some companies give their employees the option of doing with their 401(k). I do get that it was a joke, but I disagreed with what he wrote and felt like adding an insult. I hope 1997 was your birth year, and not the year of your high school graduation.

:roll: /ignore
 
I still can't believe Nintendo only made one run of these things originally - what a stupid move for them. Let's take the childish "But they wanted to make a collector's item out of it" and look at it from a real business perspective anyone could understand:

1.) It's Mario.
2.) It's the holiday season.
3.) It's only $29.99.

Anyone with a brain can tell you how the math adds up - this thing is made to sell millions of copies. Yet, their poor decision hurt both them and their customers - buyers had to shell out $40 - $50 more for this online, and none of that ends up in Nintendo's pockets.

As far as I'm concern, the reprint in coming a tad late.
 
should have never been limited. i was sold when i first found out about it at $29.99, and i thought it was disc only and not limited.
 
[quote name='Blade']The sole purpose of posting that article was to counterpoint the idea that reselling video games cannot be profitable. Again, it's just like collecting baseball cards. If anyone happens to feel that I'm wrong, and they have either a mint copy of Suikoden II, a T206 Honus Wagner or a 1952 Mickey Mantle rookie card, I'll buy it from you for $5.[/QUOTE]

Stadium Events was between 12000-41000, not averaging 41,000. Here is a PAL copy game only at $202 currently. http://cgi.ebay.com/Stadium-Events-...pt=US_Vintage_Video_Games&hash=item3364f48c67

Second, no game on the list or even close on the list is in the past 20 years. Current "Rare" games don't even top $200. Factor in that most paid 50-60 dollars it just isn't worth the hassle vs investing in stock. Buy video games to play them, not to try and resale them later for a profit.
 
[quote name='Blade']Games can still become that rare with limited production runs, initial release errors, developer/manufacturer bankruptcy, or even with enough time. Yeah, most games won't sell like that now, especially with people cracking, emulating, and torrenting games. But it could still happen. And people can easily turn a game into net profit if they're smart about it. It's just like collecting baseball cards.




The sole purpose of posting that article was to counterpoint the idea that reselling video games cannot be profitable. Again, it's just like collecting baseball cards. If anyone happens to feel that I'm wrong, and they have either a mint copy of Suikoden II, a T206 Honus Wagner or a 1952 Mickey Mantle rookie card, I'll buy it from you for $5.

Technically, you can retire at any given time. Given that Stadium Events sold for ~$41,000, the average annual income here in the United States, one could retire for a year with that given sale, then come out of retirement if they so chose. And furthermore, he was initially wrong in his assessment that you can "build" a 401(k) off from the aforementioned reselling of video games; all a 401(k) is is earned money withheld by an employer and not subjected to income tax until after retirement. Where do you propose the employer is in a "buy this exceedingly rare game, hold onto it, and resell it for a sizable profit later" scenario? One could also invest that money in stocks, like some companies give their employees the option of doing with their 401(k). I do get that it was a joke, but I disagreed with what he wrote and felt like adding an insult. I hope 1997 was your birth year, and not the year of your high school graduation.

:roll: /ignore[/QUOTE]

You're talking about two different models, however. Finding one of the handful of video games worth thousands of dollars is nearly impossible to do if you set out to do it. I've been collecting for almost twenty years now and those games almost always pop up in the hands of people who have no idea what they have and only rarely will a collector or reseller end up with a copy for far below value. Typically they end up going on Ebay right away and collectors end up with them then which is how the record prices get reached to begin with.

I'm not sure where you live, but here in California, $41K before taxes (yes, you still owe the IRS a share) would allow me to live for about six months if my wife and kids had their own source of income and didn't need me for support. You can't "retire" on that anymore than you can on unemployment. Also, for most people, having a six month or one year gap of employment makes hopping into the job market again very tough. Finally, anyone can start a 401K at anytime whether they are employed by someone else or self-employed. Many self-employed people have 401ks, so yes, even a game reseller could flip their profit into one. If you're gonna be an ass, at least get the facts straight.
 
[quote name='lordopus99']Current "Rare" games don't even top $200.[/QUOTE]

Some modern Collector's Editions can get pretty pricey. Mass Effect CE goes for up to around $600 and Dead Space Ultra Limited Edition is about the same.

[quote name='lordopus99']Stadium Events was between 12000-41000, not averaging 41,000. Here is a PAL copy game only at $202 currently. http://cgi.ebay.com/Stadium-Events-...pt=US_Vintage_Video_Games&hash=item3364f48c67[/QUOTE]
While the PAL version is still very rare compared to 99.99% of the games out there, it's no where near as scarce as the U.S. version. The one that was sold for $41,000 was a sealed U.S. copy and AFAIK there's only a few know to exist. If you're focusing solely on Stadium Events' value, then comparing the PAL and U.S. versions are apples and oranges.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
bread's done
Back
Top