I was told by the returns CSR that I could get three games this week during B2G1 and exchange them next week. It seems logical but I was curious if you could chime in on your thoughts.
My two cents. It's not something that my store would do. It's not something our return or even exchange system supports. I'll explain
Exchanging them on your receipt would make the return value of said $60 game $40. You would have to return them since games cannot be even exchanged for different games. The only reason people are getting Price Matches this week for returns and exchanges is because the promotion is still going on. Even then the policy is all 3 must be returned and then rebought with the game you want. So returning it via your receipt is not doable once this week ends if you're wanting 3 games of the same value.
Have I seen people do what you've said before? Once. It ended with us staying past store close for an extra hour trying to deal with it. It's not something our computers support and it's against policy. If you really are wanting to I plead this, don't be one of those angry guests. The only way you'll be able to do it is as a return without a receipt. Even then I'm not sure how the computer will treat each game.
Normally returns without receipts the item will be refunded via gift card at a value determinate by what the previous sale price was. I don't know how much that will affect the return value due to the B2G1 going on this week. So I am fairly certain you won't get full value. Please be sure to read up on Target's return without receipt policy as certain restrictions apply that I don't want to go into details on right now.