I'll probably be jumping on them as well... I think some folks here also recommend the Fire Pro Wrestling game - It's been this price before, but tempted now...
Yeah, it's great.
Tons of wrestlers in The Workshop. I must have over 700+ loaded - with different leagues and all: NJPW, Impact, MLW and other Indies, WWE NXT, WWE Raw, WWE SD, old school ECW, etc etc. I need to check the Workshop and update - maybe get some AEW stuff on there too!
I do wish there were more matches types, as there's mostly One on One, Tag, and Hardcore Matches. Granted, there ain't many match types in NJPW normally - but I love how WWE has so many match types, especially in 2K19 (Ladder, Cage, HIAC, MITB, Tag 3 on 3, FFA Multi-Man Matches, RR, BR, One Fall and numerous variations that you can customize (one fall, elimination, etc).
You can't go all out w/ big moves early, or you'll tire out early and likely lose. Can't waste moves here; you need to be precise, strategic, and know when to throw a move at the right time. Need to start and work from chain wrestling (holds; headlocks; grapples; etc) before you can work up to bigger moves (suplexes, slams, aerial moves, running moves, DDT's, clotheslines, etc) in a match - which is very similar to how most modern NJPW matches go, these day and age. This might even be more sim-y than the WWE games, which are also now more sim-y than arcade-y on the combat.
I also wish in your Finishers List in FPWW, there were separate finishers for Tag and Solo moves like WWE 2K series does. Feels like a waste of a finisher, if you stick someone with a Tag Finisher (like say The Young Bucks, Dudleyz, etc) - and you often are just doing solo matches.
FPWW is missing a campaign mode out the box unless you get DLC's, so...I'm tempted by the NJPW-based DLC's b/c of the modes and the tons of wrestlers each pack officially gives. But, since I bought WWE 2K19 Deluxe recently (which is also really good and customizable), might wait; unsure.
Also feels like FPWW is missing a Seasonal-like MyUniverse Mode where you can book shows, titles, events, PPV's, feuds/rivalries, sim some matches on shows, and other cool things.
Regardless, even despite everything, FPWW is really good. Highly recommend it.