I was going to post this in the GDC thread, but it's over so we can let it die out. Enjoy this long winded post:
Anyway, I was just in class and it was boring as shit, so I thought about Home, Little Big World, and "accessibility" in this gen. For months, we've all heard about how the Wii is for everyone, the big blue ocean strategy, etc. But, as we all know, the Wii also kind of mired in the last gen, performance-wise. For me, this is a problem. It's simple, which is nice, but to attract people, I feel that the product doesn't necessarily need to be simple. There's a point where it just feels dumbed down. Yes, the Wii feels a bit dumbed down to me, even on the level of fun...everybody has fun with Wii sports, my whole family enjoys it, but I'm only happy that they're happy when they play it--I don't necessarily enjoy Wii sports. It's great but it's like Nintendo just wants everyone in on it. Like that friend who invites every last person to the party, they mean well, but you don't necessarily enjoy the results. The Wii shuns the non-nintendo-diehard hardcore gamer in a way, aside from the obvious games like Zelda.
On a side note, XBLA is clearly for males 18-30 or whatever the demographic is, so it hardly bears mentioning. It's looking for the kind of hardcore gamer that's into FPS, action games in general, while throwing a bone to some casual gamers. But I can't imagine owning a 360 as a casual gamer and being satisfied with the XBLA offerings. They said that XBL will appeal to everyone at E3 (velocity girl) but that's just not going to happen. What they offer isn't enough, though it's great.
I'm not saying the Wii and 360 failed to do anything. Their strengths will warrant owning both of them eventually, but I think Home meets this whole interactive, social OS idea in the middle--it's the MMO/Sims set up that millions of people are already familiarized with, it's fully customizable, which will undoubtedly drag a lot of people in, and it's just beautiful to look at. You have casual fun games like pool and bowling (probably more) and you can hop into a casual game like Little Big World with your friends. or you can take it a step further and hop into a full featured "gamer's game." You can watch a movie or listen to music with other people online, or just sit there and talk. whatever, I doubt how much I personally will use this stuff, but all these little things will add up to a large number of people enjoying it. Don't even get me started on Singstar. I think 1Up said it right when they said it would "print money."
If that isn't highly accessible, I don't know what is. It excludes some people, like the controller impaired, but in general, I think the sleek Home set up will lure a lot of people in.
The best part-- it has features that will attract more casual players without selling short the more experienced gamers and people looking for a next gen experience.
So what we have now isn't just a game/blu-ray player with some weak online offerings. I might be wrong, but I think Sony nailed it this gen. The only thing that'll hold them back is the price tag
oh and watch the microtransactions.