Sometimes you think reviewers forget that games are supposed to be fun to play, ya know? This game is a nice change of pace for a football fan, I absolutely love it.
Both games are excellent, but boy does 2k ever have issues. It has framerate problems more often than not, and that's very annoying for a game that is relying on timing. Live has no such issues, and it's silky smooth.
What? It's been at a premium for quite some time, it's not like Gamestop is the only place selling it like that. I saw an auction close at like 75 for it...
What? It's not like the PS3 has a history of trouble anyway, there is nothing wrong with getting a refurb, and you would have 30 days to play it and try it out anyway.