[quote name='Mojimbo']Why did your opinion of GH:WT sour, munch?[/QUOTE]
Not that I've played an early release of the game for the last 4 days, but the videos indicate a few problems.
The vocals are shitty, according to my wife. They aren't as responsive as Rock Band's. She says they don't register very well.
The "there's a string between the notes so you just have to hammer on" is really gay too. I don't care for that at all.
The presentation is really shitty compared to Rock Band, and the way EVERYONE goes to Star Power at the same time really sucks. While playing I'm completely clueless as to how much Star Power I have left. This is a minor gripe, but I do like knowing how many stars I have.
The setlist is good, but the majority of the stuff is on Rock Band too. The Tool songs are the shit. Some say the notes are overcharted, but I say they're pussies. I like the notechart more on GH for guitar.
The game just feels stale compared to Rock Band. All of the new ideas seem like gimmicks. Rock Band just nailed it.