Count me among those that haven't been scared at all, and underwater stuff normally freaks me out. I have a hard time watching any deep sea documentaries. Creepy atmosphere, but hasn't made me jump yet. Condemned made me jump at parts.
Loving the game so far but I have some issues with it. I don't mind not being able to block with the wrench. I do mind that the game locked up on me to the point of needed a reset and it's not my 360. Lost an hour like than and that's never fun. I've seen a lot of bodies on the ground continue to twich, mostly their hands like they're waving which isn't a big issue, just odd. I hold the A button down while looking through things twice(tonic thing) and it plays the last audiotape over again. I wish that had been mapped differently. I love the powers but almost wish that the game would pause when holding down the left bumper. When I've got 5 powers equiped and the crap hits the fan I'm flipping through powers trying to strategize while my health is dropping. I love the audioclip stories and exploring, but I still don't know anything about the character I'm playing as. I know the story is about Rapture, but so far all I know about the main character is that he has a pair of hands.
Still very minor issues in what is otherwise a great game. It's one of those games that you just want to see what's in the next room, or the room after and end up playing it for a couple hours while barely realizing it.