[quote name='TheLongshot']I think much of the disappointment here comes from the high expectation that came from this being a Disney title.[/quote]
That doesn't do anything for me since most of Disney's games are pretty terrible (although they're trying to change that). What blows me away is that this is Warren Spector. He seemed really defensive about it in Game Informer...and it's like dude, your game sucks.
If you are a big Disney fan and like all the references that are stuck throughout the game, you are going to get more out of the game than someone who is just looking for a good game. For the latter, you will get more reward out of playing SMG.
You'll get far more out of a competent game either way.
And I don't know about the Disney fan thing. MAYBE if you have knowledge of all these obscure 20s, 30s type Disney shorts? I don't have that much knowledge about them so I can't judge.
But that's not what you think when you think "Disney Fan". Disney fans are going to get a lot out of Kingdom hearts, where you've got stuff the average person has actually seen, from 40's stuff clear through to stuff from the past decade or two. On top of that Kingdom Hearts looks and sounds great, with all the voice actors they could get.
This has basically no voice acting, and if the graphics look like anything, they sure don't look like anything from the 40's on, and are horrible judged on their own merrits.
In fact for that matter, Kingdom Hearts 2 had this awesome sequence from like Steamboat Willie type era, and IT was awesome and looked awesome...
So...MAYBE Epic Mickey is cool for some VERY specific fans of Disney, but for most it's just entirely generic.
[quote name='Altanis']What everyone says is true. The camera is
HORRIBLE. It's god awful. I can deal with bad camerawork, but this takes the cake. The game itself was pretty good, but the damned camera ruined it. [/quote]
I actually wasn't that annoyed by the camera...I though that was about the least of the game's problems.
Epic Mickey was supposed to be a Wii GOTY challenger. IMO, it's the biggest 2010 disappointment on the Wii.
Biggest disappointment of the year period IMO.
[quote name='bluesyncopate']Plusses:
* Art Design is amazing[/quote]
I think it's awful. It's dark, murky, doesn't look like anything, has this lame "theme park" vibe to it, etc.
* Some of the level designs* are absolutely ingenious - esp. with the paint/thinner mechanic.
Mario Sunshine did more and better with this IMO, and I'm sure I've seen something similar to it before, though I can't place where (sort of De Blob, but I know there's more than that too). I don't remember seeing ANYTHING interesting with that mechanic in Epic Mickey, as far as I got. And the control for it was super frustrating, far more so than the camera IMO. Just moving around in this game sucked.
Also nothing's saved when you exit an area and come back, making it feel even more pointless.
* The musical score is really, really good. The main tune from Ventureland is particularly noteworthy. Good stuff here.
I barely remember the music, and wasn't impressed by any of it.