[quote name='J7.']That sounds right. Sounds shady on Gamestop's part to gut games, try to sell them as new as they are/were, and then make them used if they don't sell. You'd think it would be illegal to sell used games as new and new games as used. Since they somehow created that scenario, which is a little mindboggling.[/quote]
Don't really see how it's shady.
It would definitely be shady if you ordered a new game online, and they sent you a clearly used one. Now, some people have claimed this has happened to them on
GS.com/EB.com, but I honestly have never seen it. Don't want to get into a pissing match with anyone, but I'm just saying it's never happened to me (probably ordered about a few dozen new games from them), and I don't know anyone who it has happened to, and I have plenty of gaming friends.
I am certainly not the biggest fan of GS's open "new" policy, but as long as you are in the store, you can clearly see what you are buying. Whenever they try to push the opened copies on me, I ask if they have any sealed ones. If they don't, I walk away. I've bought opened copies once or twice, but only when a game is somewhat difficult to find, and I don't wanna waste time and gas driving around.
As long as the games are "new," as in they haven't been used, I don't see why they shouldn't be allowed to do it. If there was something illegal about it, I'm sure someone would have brought a suit against them already, considering the wealth of crazy class-action suits we see in the US.