[quote name='Rei no Otaku']Bioshock was my #2, I hate FPS games so CoD4 isn't even close, Crackdown I played through once and never wanted to touch it again so no, Uncharted was #3 because of the shark jumping in the last bit with the zombies and the fact that every enemy took like 500 bullets to kill (fixed in the second game luckily), and NGS was worse than NGB so no. Yup, ME all the way.[/QUOTE]
Bioshock did start to suck toward the end... which is probably why I wouldn't necessarily put it at the top of the list. CoD4 redefined the multiplayer experience -- to the point where people were dropping Halo 3 (also 2007) for it after a month or two. They put together such a good formula (and it still works in MW2) -- wouldn't expect you to buy that though, since you don't go online with it. Uncharted was better than I expected and a damn impressive feat, but playing through it again now, the gameplay mechanics you criticize are true and then some (especially on crushing). NGS was

ing awesome. Never played NGB, so I can't compare it, but hey, it looked good, played great, had ninjas and bouncing boobs... A+ here... I really want to check out sigma sometime, but I'm totally waiting for a pricedrop. Crackdown was a blast -- did I go back to it once I beat it and got most of the achievements - no, but then again, by the time I played it, it was mid-2008 and nobody was playing anymore so I had to roll solo.
Tom Brady as a space marine, some wonky combat (maybe if biotics were a bit better... but by the time I realized I hated all biotics, I'd invested so much time in Liara that switching to someone else seemed silly), really bad mako driving and forced planet exploration, and a story i couldn't get into all in a western-RPG set in space? Definitely below all the others, I listed, IMO. A solid game, but unlike you with your dragon age and 7080321948 playthroughs, i thought about playing a new game plus, but didn't care enough about anything to actually start it. The game was put down and I've never picked it up again.
It'll be interesting to see how they changed the new one. Hopefully be interesting, and the combat will be praised beyond all measure...