[quote name='botticus']Eh... I'd say no... maybe a GC title released around Revolution launch, but not for the Revolution. I don't think I'm the only person not planning on getting a Revolution the day it comes out, so that would really limit its impact. Whereas if you release it for GC, it can still technically be a "launch title" as a result of backwards compatibility.[/QUOTE]
You need to view the issue from Nintendo's perspective. If they release it at launch as an actual Revolution game, and not simply a backwards compatible GameCube game, then people will have a very big reason to want and need the Revolution on day 1. It is something to get excited about for the new system. Also, releasing a high profile game that late in a console's life cycle can be a big mistake because many people are already in next gen mode and ready for the new stuff, and an "old" game, even if it is Zelda, might be ignored by people who would normally buy it on day 1. The last thing they want is something like the GameCube launch where their big release was Luigi's Mansion. A good launch lineup needs an exclusive flagship title and then a great group of support from other high quality exclusive titles, along with a decent selection of non-exclusive games. The problem with the GameCube launch is that there was no flagship title, and you could argue that the 3rd party support was a little weak, although it didn't vary too much from the competition for their launches. I would love if the Revolution could also launch with great supporting games like Smash Bros. (which has already been announced), Pikmin, Super Monkey Ball, Rogue Squadron, etc. as the GameCube did, but without Zelda or Mario at launch, a lot of previously dedicated Nintendo fans might not care about the launch as much. Unless I have an extra bit of cash next fall, I don't see myself picking up the Revolution on day 1 unless there is a big reason to do so, and a next gen Zelda, one that by that time would have been in development for 3.5 years, would quite possibly be the biggest reason I could imagine for a Nintendo console.