[quote name='Feeding the Abscess']Marion really came into the league at the wrong time. His eight and a half season run with Phoenix was overshadowed by Duncan and KG's peaks. Otherwise, Marion probably would have had 4 or 5 first team all defense selections. In my own fantasy world, I'd time warp back to 2003 and put AK-47 and Matrix at 3 and 4 and watch the fun.
Can't agree with you on Marion winning DPOY or 1st team all defense though. I don't think he beats out Ibaka, Josh Smith, Brand/Iguodala (not sure they'd classify Iggy as a F for this award, but one of those guys needs to be on the team), or even Durant or Garnett. Definitely won't beat out LeBron. Kevin Love will probably get votes for his rebounding.[/QUOTE]
Marion has straight up punked everyone this year with the exception of Jeremy Lin (the first game) and Lebron. When you guard 1-4 and shut people down, you got to be worthy of the award. No one thought the Mav's would be a top five defensive team this year and the only reason they are there is because of Marion (Haywood and West have been solid as well, but they haven't had to deal with the guys Marion has).
http://espn.go.com/blog/dallas/mave...ould-shawn-marion-be-a-leading-dpoy-candidate
Ibaka, Smith, and Iggy are all solid D guys, but Smith has been a C all year and Ibaka gets a ton of help inside from Perk to make the kind of plays he does. Not discounting his skill set, but he isn't as good an on the ball defender. He is a stellar help defender.
Durant isn't that good of a defender. If Ibaka or Durant were solid on the ball defenders they wouldn't have let Dirk destroy them in the playoffs.
I know I am biased, but Matrix went out and put on a clinic in the fourth quarter on both ends of the floor tonight so I have to pump him up. Ibaka, Chandler, and Howard probably all will rank higher than him in DPOY awards, but he could be that Karl Malone type candidate and come out and steal it away in the make up vote.