I don't know why I'm bothering, should follow Jesse's lead, but...
[quote name='wolftrader']Stop drinking the Kool-aid, and buy a real gaming/entertainment system.[/quote]
Last time I checked, teh 360 most certainly is a real game system. I haven't listened to the show in a while, and I did dislike some of the Sony bashing I heard on there last year, but I can't comment now.
1. Red Ring of Death- Would you buy a pacemaker with a 30% failure rate (and that's being generous) for your heart... I would not! Most of my friends are on their 3rd console while my first Sony is pluggung along just fine
It was terrible, no question, but it's gotten much better with Falcon, and should be better still with Jasper. I don't think reliability is too big of an issue now, at least I hope not. I'm actually debating whether to buy a new Wii, as my one from last year died (with much less play time than my PS3/360 ever get).
2. So how does it feel having a Beta-max video player? Blue Ray is the future, and Sony has it!
Yeah, Sony has it which is cool, but stand alone players are pretty cheap now, and obviously you can still do really good games with the storage space DVD gives you. I'm not really sure either decision was "wrong".
And DVD's not dead yet (and the PS3 plays it too...though yeah, at this point I want to do everything Blu Ray when I can).
Not the Xbox and its outdated tech. It allows games to be made that the Xbox could not keep up with due to it's outdated tech for a player
I don't know about that. I'm honestly not sure how that's going to play out. We've already seen 4 disc 360 games, and that'll probably become more common. The PS3's storage space may never be used all that well in third party games though since they have to worry about fitting the assets onto a DVD. Although I guess Bioshock has higher resolution textures on the PS3 (although that may be a GPU thing versus storage space).
3.It's loud as hell! Who turned on the compressor!
I agree, it's crazy they released it like that, and that alone would be a reason for me to standardize on PS3...BUT that's sort of getting fixed in just one week. Microsoft's new firmware allows you to install games to the drive, and keep it spun down (except for a disc check). My 360 is still louder without it's drive spinning, but at least it's more comparable, and I don't think will drive me as nuts.
4. Paying for Online play! Add in the extra cost you pay for Online play
It depends on the person. For some people paying for a apparently (?) better service is well worth it, for others (like me) it isn't at all-so the 360 effectively has no online for me. But I'm not sure that one is really "better" than other other in any absolute sense, just depends on the person.
5. Xbox is already planning a 2010 Xbox720 because they cant eeck out any more power from their lawnmower sized engine!
We don't know what Microsoft is planning. Both Microsoft and Sony (and Nintendo) have next gen (or current gen in Nintendo's case) systems in the works, and probably did before their current systems launched. I suspect that both Microsoft and Sony are going to keep these systems around longer than normal. I'm expecting both to last at least 6 years before getting replaced. I mean right now their biggest competitor is a last gen system (the Wii) so why rush out something new, when these systems are still struggling to come down in price, get refined, etc.
I do think the PS3 has further it can be pushed, since it does have more raw power but is harder to code for, and has more storage space, but even still, there's a LOT of new gameplay waiting on both of these systems! Already we've seen amazing new experiences that weren't possible until now, and that's going ton continue for years.
7. Microsoft are notoriously hard to work with in developing titles, add this to the lack of HP and you get a lot of mediocre games.
I've heard nothing about that before, and I don't know what "HP" is. I've always heard terrible things about Nintendo's third party relationships, and Sony recently apparently caused the demise of Working Designs. Microsoft as far as I know has been okay so far-but then they're the underdog. We've seen in their other endeavors that they're incredibly nasty when they want to be, so if they ever make it to the top they'll probably be bad too...but right now from what I heard they're fine to work with.
Xbox pours tons of money into the advertisment, to drown out the bad facts they want buried.
To their credit, they're trying to FIX most of those issues (except the d-pad...) They're not doing anything unusual with advertising versus anyone else.
We all own 360s because we like the exclusives-same reason we own PS3s and Wiis and PCs and DS and PSPs (and I bet I'm not the only one with all of them!

)