[quote name='jh6269']@BattleChicken and others who are not blaming the hacker,
It most certainly is the hacker's fault. If he wouldn't have tried to crack the PS3, the Other OS option would have stayed. The guy created a maintenance nightmare for Sony, so they're cutting the option out completely before the pirates and the scammers try to use it to create root kits and phishing scams for PS3s.
Anyway, you aren't forced to update, you just can't access PSN if you don't do the update. Sony just doesn't want compromised systems on their network--and rightfully so.
This is how life always is, some small group of individuals has to ruin it for everyone--this is no different. Maybe people will finally learn not to do this kind of crap. If the hacker wanted to mod his system, fine, but he didn't have to publicize it. The guy is just an irresponsible douche, so if you want to blame someone, blame the hacker.[/QUOTE]
You're not going to get "rootkits and phishing scams" because of OtherOS. What is ironic is you COULD get a rootkit courtesy of SONY if you played one of their CDs in your computer back a few years ago! So trying to pretend that Sony is some white knight on a horse here is really missing the mark.
Even if it was cracked wide open, IT WOULD NOT AFFECT YOUR SECURITY ONE BIT UNLESS YOU INSTALLED SOMETHING. There is so much misunderstanding of what is happening-- and therefore "Sony is awesome, please protect me!" attitudes-- it's really frustrating. YOUR unhacked PS3 would continue to not run unsigned code, so nothing written by a hacker would ever run. It would only run on hacked PS3s. That's the whole point of hacking.
ALL OtherOS does is open up your system to allow you to install another OS. This is the FIRST STEP-- it won't allow you to run Linux in the background while you're running PS3 games, it's not an attack vector in and of itself for malicious code to run. OtherOS basically sets up your PS3 to be a dual-boot computer, with a PS3 mode and an OtherOS mode. They're entirely separate. Sony extremely limits what can be done in OtherOS mode-- no access to the graphics chip, for example. This also prevents developers from using OtherOS to be a super cheap dev kit and keep their real dev kits really expensive.
This hack STILL REQUIRES you to open your PS3, solder in some additional equipment, and does not (at this time) allow you to play games. Sony, instead of fixing whatever vulnerability exists, just goes and turns off the feature, pats itself on the back, and makes up a bunch of total BS about "security" and "bogeymen" and stuff to scare people.
And if Sony thinks the problem is bad now, when it's basically an unexploitable and untouchable hack for all but the most super dedicated, they've opened the barn door with this idiotic reponse. Hackers try to hack systems to do what they want them to do-- like tweaking a car to get more MPG or go faster or whatever. Pirates then come in and take what the hackers did and make it run pirated stuff. The problem is, without the hackers paving the way, the other groups would have no clue what to do.
So what happens now? Hackers were more or less staying away from the PS3 as a hacking platform-- it already ran Linux, could do what they wanted, and there wasn't much of a need to do anything. However, now that Sony is closing up the option, it's the perfect excuse to hack the hell out of the PS3 and prove their superiority to Sony. And I have no doubt who is going to win, and it won't be pretty for Sony. They've pissed off the very people who understand their hardware, probably better than they do, and are in a position to really embarrass Sony.
And if you don't update, it's not just you "can't access PSN" -- you eventually won't be able to play new games that require newer firmware. You eventually won't be able to play new Bluray discs that need newer firmware. Your system basically becomes a relic, frozen in time with what the PS3 was capable of playing on March 31, 2010. Thanks to content producers becoming obsessed with DRM and preventing LEGAL owners from doing what they want (because the pirates have pirated copies they can distribute, copy, etc), PS3 owners who WANT TO KEEP THE FEATURES THE SYSTEM SHIPPED WITH won't be able to also use the system into the future. Sony is forcing people to decide now-- for once and for all, since we all know you can't downgrade-- what they want to do. And if you choose the wrong answer and decide you wanted to do the other path, sorry, tough.
Again, this has nothing to do with YOUR security. That's a complete line of BS fed to you by Sony. This has EVERYTHING to do with Sony's corporate paranoia. Someone, somewhere, somehow is possibly doing something that may or may not be something Sony feels is acceptable. And Sony's going to nuke millions of PS3s' capabilities, instead of FIXING THE PROBLEM.
This is sort of like demolishing one room in your house when the room needs painting-- too much hassle to paint, so let's just tear it down and forget it ever existed.