When you compare some GOTY contenders, I don't see how anyone in their right mind would put MW2 over Uncharted 2. There are so many similar things that Uncharted 2 does right that Modern Warfare 2 does wrong, especially the AI:
- In Uncharted 2, your allies can shoot and aim quite well
- In Modern Warfare 2, your allies can't hit butter
- In Uncharted 2, your allies can distract enemies and take down enemies by themselves
- In Modern Warfare 2, your allies are distracted by butterflies